Batteries: The Invention That Untethered the World
Batteries TodayIntro
So, Ben, you've been getting any funny looks when you tell people what this next project's about?
Yeah, but less than when we were working on the Story of Coal.
True.
You get some blank faces when you tell me you spent the last, what, half year trying to understand the history of batteries.
Who would have thought, man, it's such a wild story. These tiny little cells inside of everything.
How could you not be completely fascinated?
The time has come. We got to give them their due. I'm fully charged.
Hello, and welcome to the fifth episode of the Stepchange Show. We cover the stories of human progress, the technologies, systems and infrastructure that shape our world. And I'm Ben Shwab Eidelson, co founder of Stepchange Ventures, a fund that invests in accelerating today's biggest step changes. I'm based up in Seattle, Washington.
And I'm Anay Shah, fellow co founder of Stepchange Ventures, based in Los Angeles, California. Today, we're telling the story of batteries.
Why batteries? Well, batteries are a marvel. You see, every day, we carry around these little packages of chemistry that miraculously give us energy on demand. Just today, I have a battery in my pocket. I have one strapped on my wrist, and I have one powering my car on the way to drop the kids off at school.
But batteries are easy to overlook because they've been sitting inside of other things for over a century. And going into the story, we didn't fully appreciate how often a battery was literally the thing that made a new product possible. The telegraph. The first time a message between people could move faster than a horse ran on batteries. So did the first radios connecting Americans across living rooms. Many of the first cars were, in fact, battery powered. And every car since has needed a battery to get it started.
Batteries have powered warfare, from the bazookas fired by troops to the submarines used in World War II.
And all of that is a half century before the lithium-ion battery powered a personal device revolution, including camcorders, music players, phones, and laptops. From the smallest devices in our lives to the largest machines that humankind has ever made, there is now a battery in the middle. Making it all work
and scale has been the key to making batteries cheap enough to be usable. Today, batteries demonstrate a near perfect learning curve. You know, every time the world's cumulative battery production has doubled, the price has fallen by 20%.
In 2010, the whole world could make about 20 gigawatt-hours of lithium-ion batteries a year. In 2024, just 14 years later, we made more than 1,000 gigawatt-hours. That's 50 times the capacity. And in that same period, the cost of a battery pack dropped by over 90%, meaning that same size battery pack is now a tenth of the cost in less than a decade and a half.
And this immense drop in cost has rippled through markets. You have the EV revolution in full swing, with nearly one in three new cars sold around the world today being plugged in instead of having to go to the gasoline pump. In China, it's over half of new cars. And as the car market has gotten to mass production, the grid has followed. You know, today when I flip on my lights here in California, it's more likely that my power is coming from a battery than a gas plant.
And it's hard to overstate just how new this all is. Nearly all the battery capacity on the grid was built since 2020, and most of that in the last two to three years. And all of this is why we think batteries are one of the most important energy technologies of this century. And that we are now living through the moment, the step change. And so, to understand where we are in today's explosion of batteries and the resulting geopolitical entanglement, we need to do what we like to do best. Go back in time to appreciate how we got here and answer some of our biggest questions.
Like how did early batteries first change the daily lives of Americans? And why did we first replace horses with EVs and then retreat to gasoline for over a century?
And how did China come to fully dominate this market? And what does it mean for the Western world now? And how are batteries going to fundamentally reshape how our grid operates?
And so today we're telling the story of a technology that enables freedom, an untethering of energy from generation, the ability to move us quietly and cleanly through the world and to bring energy with us wherever we go.
This is the story of batteries.
But before we get into it, just one quick note. We have all of the research links, notes for this episode and even an interactive guide to batteries up at Stepchange Show. And while this is only the fifth episode of the Stepchange Show, we're deeply appreciative of over 200,000 listeners who who have joined us on these wild four hour journeys. This has only happened because it's being shared amongst folks. And so if you're listening to this and you think of a friend or colleague who might enjoy it, please text it over their way so they can listen in together.
It's like a book club for your ears.
And a huge thank you to our friends at Base Power our presenting sponsor for this episode.
Yeah, there really couldn't be a better partner for the evolving story and applications of batteries. And we'll get to what Base is doing in just a little bit.
So where do we begin? The story of batteries.
Early Science1780–1927
So let's talk about the first moment when a real chemical battery was discovered. That first bit of current, it wasn't lithium-ion, it wasn't lead–acid, or it wasn't double A or 9 volt alkaline battery. Was it
this battery on my desk, it didn't start there.
It wasn't even the old trick of making a battery out of a lemon, where you take a penny and a nail and you get some current. What was it? It was a frog. So let's travel to Italy in 1780. Luigi Galvani is a physician and anatomist at a university. And so he's sitting there dissecting a frog with a scalpel. The metal touches one of the frog's nerves and the leg kicks. And so he becomes intrigued and digs in. He starts hanging frog's legs by brass hooks on iron railings of a balcony to see if a thunderstorm is making them twitch or they somehow attracting this electricity.
But they twitch. With no storm and no active electricity being generated, Whenever the brass hooks and the iron rail are both touching the frog legs, they're twitching. And he actually draws the exact wrong conclusion of this. He believes that with no outside electricity, it has to be coming from inside the frog. The frog has to be generating this animal electricity, when in fact, he just made a frog battery. And so, after 10 more years of experiments, Galvani publishes a book about this. His claim is that the brain secretes this electric fluid.
Nerves carry it, and each muscle fiber stores this electric energy.
This is breaking news. The theory starts spreading across Europe. There's a legend that an Italian physician named Valli wrote to a colleague and says, sir, I want frogs. You must find them. I will never pardon you, sir, if you fail to do so.
There's these frog shortages potentially happening because people want to study this electricity and demonstrate it at parties. Well, this theory hits another scientist who was not convinced of this animal electricity.
This is Alessandro Volta, a professor of physics and an instrument maker. He repeats Galvani's experiments and finds the results astonishing at first. Then he notices it's actually two different metals. The frog's leg is working as a conductor of electricity and as a detector of it. And the current comes from the two different metals.
Forget the voltmeter, you just want some frog legs to twitch.
That's right. And it turns out his favorite detector becomes his own tongue when he lays across a coin and a piece of zinc. So the frog, it turns out, is not the source of electricity. It's an electrolyte and a voltmeter. And to prove the frog is only a detector, Volta needs a device that makes electricity with no animal involved. He puts a zinc disk with a silver disc, with a disc of cardboard soaked in saltwater and repeats that pattern over and over again. At first he calls it an artificial electric organ and writes that a column composed of about 40 pairs of metals is already sufficient to produce noticeable effects.
Each zinc pair gives about three quarters of a volt. And so the voltage adds up to a stack where 40 pairs gives 30 volts. And this stacking of cells in series adds voltage. Introducing the voltaic pile.
And this voltaic pile really is our first constructed battery.
Now this pile is the first device in history to convert chemical energy into steady electric current. Contemporaries call it the last great discovery. We think we've opened up man to a new and incomparable source of energy. Now the challenge is that that this continuous current does kill the pile in a matter of hours. But it is such an incredible breakthrough that scientists all over Europe are buzzing about.
Why is this such a big deal? Well, let's remember where we are in the journey of understanding electricity through the 1700s. There are moments of discovery, like Franklin flying his kite to determine that lightning was in fact electricity. And a bunch of parlor tricks shocking people with stored up charge. But no one had a source of steady flowing current. The first generators and dynamos are 50 years away. So the voltaic pile is revolutionary and giving us current. So what do scientists do with all this new current from these piles?
Well, the first big thing is for discovery. So for the first time they can run an electric current through water and they see that the water splits into two different gases, hydrogen and oxygen. This is electrolysis. It's the discovery that electricity can pull a compound apart into its separate elements. And the science community goes wild with this. The scientist who takes us the furthest is Humphry Davy. He's working as a chemist at the Royal Institution and his job is to be both a scientist but also a bit of a showman.
He's giving talks to share science with the public and he's this young, handsome stage performer that would pack the house with his lectures. Supposedly there would be traffic jams on the way to get into his shows and he wants a bigger and bigger battery. So he goes to The Royal Institution and asks for funding for the biggest battery possible. They start with 24 copper and zinc plates over the decade. They're going to grow that to a 2000 plate voltaic pile. Why does he want a bigger battery? Well, he wants to do more impressive demonstrations and discover new things.
He starts hooking up these piles into filaments and enables the first incandescent light. He starts arcing electricity between carbon rods, which is the arc light. And then a string of element discoveries. He turns to the non existent yet periodic table and starts filling it out. First he takes lye and runs the voltaic pile through it. And metallic potassium starts forming in these silvery bubbles. This is the discovery of the element potassium, sodium then follows a few days later. Then barium, calcium, magnesium.
He's gotten compound after compound in a matter of weeks. And these are all compounds that you couldn't melt apart with fire, but you could now split with electrolysis. And if you look in the periodic table, all of these new elements that they're discovering sit in the upper left corner. These are all elements that naturally like to lock up into salts and minerals. But there's one more even a bit higher up that's a bit lighter that nobody has discovered yet. And a few years later, a young chemist in Stockholm finds a mineral that contains this element.
He decides to name the element lithium, meaning from the stone in Greek, because unlike sodium and potassium, it comes out of a hard rock versus salts. And Davey manages to isolate a few specks of lithium metal. But it's going to be a century and a half before lithium becomes the elemental protagonist in the story of batteries. But what else is going on in science in this period?
And so here about the 1820s, you've got electricity and magnetism that's being taught as two unrelated forces, right? You've got magnets and compasses on one side, you've got batteries with chemistry and some folks thinking about lightning on the other. A scientist called Ampere is working out how wires attract or repel each other. And he writes out these laws of electromagnetism. Fast forward a few years and you're able to wrap a wire around a piece of iron and create a really strong magnet. And by the 1830s, people are able to pick up a ton of weight with a battery, which is just mind blowing, right?
Like prior to this, all of human history is using people and animal power, and suddenly you're able to pick up a chunk of iron,
and all of this is being driven by larger and larger voltaic piles, right? All of the scientific discovery, all of this fundamental physics is happening because we've now have the source of current.
And then later, an American, Joseph Henry, demonstrates the magnetic telegraph. So he strings a mile of wire around his room and demonstrates that he can actually ring a bell. And so if a battery can move a needle to ring a bell, it can send a message. That same year, Faraday figures it out in reverse. How do you use magnetism to create electricity? This would lead to the dynamo, which would turn coal into electricity.
Now you hear these different names. Turn on a pile, Turn on batteries. So just a quick side note, if you go back to our grid episode, we talk about the origin of the word battery, which was first used by Benjamin Franklin when he connected a bunch of capacitors called leiden jars back 30 to 40 years before the story we're in now. And he called those rows of jars a battery. And that's what became the English word for this whole notion of stored electric charge. So we're here in the early 1830s, and a battery at this point was something you bought essentially, like we said, just to do science with it, Right?
The buyers were lecturers, they were chemists, maybe a handful of people experimenting with the idea of communication. But this functional problem remained. Within a couple hours, hydrogen coated a plate, and the current would drop away and the battery was dead. So a lot of things were tried. But the key solution unlocked was to separate out the two sides of the battery more significantly. First, starting with a porous clay wall that let ions through, but kept the metals apart from each other. And so then what you'd see is the zinc plate would slowly thin, while the copper plate on the other side thickens, and you get a constant current throughout this process.
This is called a constant battery or a Daniell cell. And this unlocks the first time a real applied use of batteries, particularly with communications and the Telegraph. In 1838, Samuel Morse develops a code, Morse code of dots and dashes, designed to actually record a message on tape. And the first long distance line is set up from the D.C. capital to Baltimore along the B and O railway.
What's the first thing he decides to send? He sends his assistant a message.
The first official message from long distance immediate communication is what hath God wrought? This is a big moment. Right until this moment in history, every message between people was sent physically, person to person, or by mail. And so this instantaneous communication over 38 miles is such a powerful unlock unlocked by batteries. And so now the industry wants more. It wants the battery to run longer and be even More convenient. Enter this next big design innovation, where instead of having these two different vats, they put them on top of each other, but separated by densities.
This is called a gravity cell. And this battery, this gravity cell also had this convenient property where you could actually see the fluids drop down over time and know how much charge was left in the battery. This battery design became the standard across American and British telegraph networks. Up until, I believe, the 50s, these things were used. So what is actually going on inside of these vats of chemicals to give you power? And over this story, we're going to run into a lot of different battery chemistries.
The lead–acid, the nickel batteries, lithium-ion. But they all fundamentally work the same way. And so we wanted to pause for a second and give you a quick little batteries 101. And if you want a visual to go alongside this whole story, you can head to Stepchange Show batteries. You'll be able to play along with charging and discharging in all of the different battery chemistries. So, fundamentally, a battery is a reaction split into two different places. You put a material that wants to give up electrons on one side of the battery and.
And material that wants to take them on the other, and you keep those two pieces apart. You make it that the only way for electrons to get across is through a wire out through an external circuit, like your flashlight or your phone.
So there are three parts. The anode is the electron giver, or the minus end of your battery. The cathode is the electron taker, or the plus end. The electrons travel outside the battery through the circuit. Inside, you have atoms that are positively or negatively charged that move to balance out the charge and make the internal reaction happen. Atoms in this charged state are called ions. So inside, between the anode and the cathode, you have a material called an electrolyte. It could be a liquid or a paste that lets the ions through, but blocks the electrons.
So when you connect an external circuit, like flipping on your flashlight, the circuit closes, and the cathode wants electrons, and the anode wants to get rid of them. This chemical energy difference is where energy is actually stored. And in a rechargeable battery, we've made it possible for the reaction to run both ways. So you can discharge a battery, then push current back through it to undo the reaction in your car battery. Discharging it turns the lead into lead sulfate. And charging it turns it back into lead.
Now, lithium-ion batteries don't turn anything into different material. That's what makes it kind of special. Lithium ions Shuttle back and forth between the anode and the cathode, While the structures themselves remain intact. This magic shuffling of lithium ions is called intercalation.
So when the anode is charged up, think of a boulder pushed up to the top of a hill. Discharging it lets it roll down, and the electrons do the work along the way. Charging pushes the boulder back up, Ready to roll down again. The height of that hill is the voltage, and it comes from which two materials make up the cathode and the anode, not how much of the material you have. So a tiny AAA battery and a big D cell battery have the same chemistry, and they both give you 1.5 volts. The D cell just holds more of that same voltage difference.
Volta worked this out by trial and error, ranking different metals. The further apart two metals were on his list. The bigger the hill, the higher the voltage of the cell. So if you want more voltage than what the one cell can give you, you can stack cells end to end in series. That's why his pile was a pile and why there are six little 1.5 volt cells inside one of your 9 volt batteries. If you want more capacity, you want the batteries to last longer, you, you put the cells side by side in parallel. So when you flip on a flashlight, how does the energy actually get to the light bulb?
Well, think about a wave in the ocean. There's a lot of energy moving through the water in the wave, but each individual drop of water barely goes anywhere. The energy inside a battery travels in a similar way. You put the aa battery in your flashlight, you turn it on, and then an electric and magnetic field forms around the wires. And the energy travels through that field from the battery into the bulb at nearly the speed of light. The electrons themselves shuffle very slowly through that loop. And inside the battery, a parallel thing is going on.
Ions do that same slow shuffle through the electrolyte, Keeping the charges balanced. The reaction can keep going.
And working with materials that want to have a high energy reaction is what makes batteries hard. You see, you want materials of the anode and cathode to be the most extreme form. Fired up volatile relationship. And they're going to perform better the closer they are together. That tension is where the energy comes from. The only thing keeping these two materials apart is a layer between them. And if that layer fails, all the energy can come out at once in the form of heat. So a better performing battery also means it's one that's harder to keep from combusting.
There's so much effort that goes into manufacturing to drive that tension to precision, to get more energy out of that battery consistently. And so that's our batteries 101. There's one material that's giving up electrons, one that's taking them in, something in between that lets the ions flow through and some external circuit that you're doing something with, like powering your light bulb or your phone and eventually your car, These magical little containers of stored up energy are trying to find a way to be released, and that's what's powering your life.
Okay, but now back to where we are in the story. It's the late 1800s, and our batteries are still very much these vats of open liquid. That's why we call them wet cells.
We're talking 140 years ago, a company of the name of Western Union became a huge consumer of this. They had thousands of these wet cells, these gravity cells, rooms full of jars with blue liquids at the bottom, Helping the world communicate across long distances,
talk about longer distances. It's during this era that we run a line from the tip of Canada over to the tip of Ireland underwater. And so this is the beginning of transatlantic instant communication.
This is life changing, and it keeps on moving. Once people are able to communicate over long distances, they want longer conversations. They want more instantaneous conversations. They want to go from letters to. And telegraphs to. Now the telephone. Enter Alexander Graham Bell. We're in about the mid-1870s. And the telephones that he's developed carry around a wet cell in a wooden box because you've got to power the transmitter. And the problem is, like, these cells are leaking. Company has to send someone to change them.
They create a new subscription service. It's kind of a mess because you've got all of these massive jars sitting under every telephone that just get discharged.
And if we want to get these things in people's houses, dealing with that is a huge mess. And so, fortunately, in the mid-1880s, a scientist thickens the liquid into a paste using plaster of Paris and seals it in a zinc can. The can itself becomes the negative electrode. And so this didn't make them dry, even though we call them dry cells, but it made it like a thick porridge, a lot easier to handle. You could carry one around and it wouldn't spill.
You don't have a leaky jar of toxins under your desk. The change in packaging changes everything.
Goes from a thin soup to a chili. And Union Carbide is a company formed to actually go manufacture and sell these things. You can go Buy them in the store. Now they sell this standard can with these two caps on top that you can hook up to. It's called a number six cell. You'll look one of these up and it looks like a handheld thick device in this company. And these cells are the ancestor of the brand Eveready and the Energizer Bunny, which we'll get into later in the story.
I know those. So you got this dry cell that became a hit for a few key pieces of modern technology. What were those applications? Well, the first one is the telephone. Now you don't need maintenance. This is great. Then you've got the radio. Talk about life changing. The commercial radio began in around 1920, and by 1930 you had 12 million homes taking this up. This is a faster adoption than telephone or light because people want the news, they want weather updates, they want play by play, baseball and college football.
And for the first several years, every one of those ran on batteries.
I think one of the reasons it picked up faster than telephone or electric light is you didn't have to run wires to your house to get radio. You bought the device and you buy batteries at the store and you were good to go until those batteries ran down. Those Eveready cells made by Union Carbide went from 12 million sold in 1922. Four years later, 300 million. That's 24x growth in four years. So these radios just burned through batteries like nobody's business and created this booming market.
The next application is the hand torch. Now, we call that a flashlight, but the name actually comes from the fact that we could only generate a few seconds of light at a time. It was a flash of light. Now remember, before this, the only portable source of light was a fire, a candle or a kerosene lantern that had an active flame and a gust of wind would blow it out. A dry cell doesn't spill and has no flame. You can seal it in a tube and carry it anywhere. Eveready. The New York company that sold the first ones in 1899 advertised it as the light that does not flicker in a draft, extinguish in the wind, and is controlled instantly by finger pressure.
Cleverly, the company's founder handed them out to New York police officers and put their praise in his advertisements. And finally you get to the mega application, the car. And we're going to talk a lot more about the car soon. But this is about the time that the Model T comes in. And the way the Model T worked is you had to set the spark walk to the front of the car, turn a crank to fire the ignition coils to then get the engine to catch before it could switch over to the flywheel. And the set of cells that were powering this were these dry cells.
So you put these technologies together and you get hundreds of millions of cells being sold, you get dozens of manufacturers and you get a common source of electricity in everybody's hand and home. Now, a lot of these technologies would be overtaken, whether it's centralizing the phone system or bringing the grid to people's houses. You could plug in your radio. But the point is, during this period, life and society dramatically changed. And it was because of the battery that you could have communication and you could have power instantaneously.
And the applications were exploding and people started to want more power and they didn't want the pain of having to throw away their battery, go back to the store, buy some new ones and replace it.
Can't we just recharge those things?
It kind of seems like we're ready for a rechargeable battery.
Lead Acid1859–today
So this wraps our first chapter on the journey of the early battery and all of the scientific discovery and early applications of those batteries. And I think it's time for our next chapter. The story of the lead acid battery, the first battery you can recharge. And the lead acid battery is an extremely consequential battery that's going to shape the next hundred years of our story. It's deeply intertwined with attempts at electric vehicles and remains a workhorse in our lives today. As we speak, there's something like 2 billion lead acid batteries running.
Most of that's inside of our cars and trucks, even the EVs. But some still are importantly used for stationary use to power telco equipment. It's also led to some of humanity's deepest environmental harms.
But let's first go back to the discovery of this incredible powerful battery. We're not going to go to Italy this time, we're going to go to Paris, France.
Okay, so up until this point, all these batteries that we've spoken about have been one way reactions. You have to refill the chemicals almost like a fuel because the reactions would deplete the cell. We needed some way to refill them, to recharge them. Well, it's 1859 in Paris and Gaston Planté is a young 25 year old lab assistant and he was curious about this thing that had been observed for decades that was more of a nuisance. Experimenters had noticed that if you pass current through two identical metal plates, inside of an acid bath and disconnect that cell pushes a weak current back the other way.
And it was treated as this annoyance because it would mess up these otherwise clean experiments. Well, Gaston set out to catalog it systematically which metals and which solutions were causing the largest secondary current. And it turns out lead in a dilute sulfuric acid bath won out. And so he starts to make more and more significant devices out of this. He rolls up two sheets of lead with rubber strips in between into a spiral and drops it into sulfuric acid inside of a jar. And he realizes that he can push the current in and get more current back out.
And this is a breakthrough, but it takes a while for it to be really useful, because there's a couple issues. The first issue is that Planté has to run a continuous DC current repeatedly through the cell to form a lead dioxide on one of the plates in order to actually make the battery an effective rechargeable battery. And second, at this point, the only source of electricity to do that forming or charge of the battery is other battery cells. So you have to charge this lead acid battery from a gravity cell, discharge it, charge it again, back and forth, back and forth, until the lead is coated with the right oxide, and.
And then you recharge it from another battery in order to use it as a rechargeable. So it's an interesting discovery, but it's quite a process before you can get to a useful rechargeable battery. And all of this is why the industry still calls rechargeable batteries secondary cells and single use batteries, primary ones, because those are the primary cells charging the secondary cell.
Each rechargeable battery cell had to essentially be grown, and this cycle took up to a week to create that active layer. And so if this is what would continue, it would just remain an interesting scientific discovery. But as we see in the story, enter another chemist, Faure, the French chemist, who had spent a bunch of time in explosives and realized that instead of forming a layer by cycling, you can actually coat the lead with paste of lead oxide, sulfuric acid and water, and then cure it in some heat. And now you've got a cell that gets recharged in a day instead of a week.
You pair this with the fact that you can start to burn coal to create current to charge up a battery, and you see the beginnings of a product. And as soon as these first rechargeable batteries hit the world, there becomes this instant awareness of how it can transform our relationship to electricity. It can keep an engine going all day. It can keep it going all night. You can use it on the grid to balance out the swings of energy.
Yeah, I mean, it's wild studying the history of this, that as soon as this happens, as you said and I, people start talking about all the use cases for batteries that we're still talking about today. They're talking immediately about how this smooths out the capacity of their coal burning plants. And it becomes this fundamental unlock that everyone sees as immensely powerful.
Now it is worth dog and one of our favorite guys, Thomas Edison, for a moment, because he's about to flip on the Pearl Street station.
Batteries are sort of a competition in his eyes, I think, in the moment. And he sees them as a kind of at least competitive mindshare. He's pushing the central station model where you have coal plants burning and a bunch of wires running to your house.
And so he says the storage battery is, in my opinion, a catch, penny, a sensation, a mechanism for swindling the public by stock companies. Just as soon as a man gets working on the secondary battery, it brings out his latent capacity for lying. And such begins the famous line in the industry. Liars, liars, battery suppliers.
But Edison was wrong about this chemistry. As a battery, lead acid is extremely compelling. The cell gives about 2 volts, nearly double what every rival in the era was giving. Sulfuric acid is one of the most conductive liquids available. So the cell can put out enormous current without that voltage sagging. An overcharging lead acid battery doesn't cause it to explode. It just bubbles off water rather than starting a fire. So we finally have rechargeable lead acid battery. Anaya, what are we going to do with it?
Well, its killer feature is that it stays charged and it can be called upon when needed, Deliver a pretty significant amount of power, and then get charged up again to keep on working for you. One of the first major uses was improving the phone system. Remember, the way that bell designed the phone system was that every phone had had its own battery hooked up to it. And as we talked about, people have to manage these messy batteries and the leaking and the servicing, it was a mess. Instead, if you put a stronger common battery across a central line, you can get rid of the batteries at the home.
So now you can lift up that receiver and you get this smooth, buttery, consistent current and you're connected, ready to go. Once lead acid batteries have smoothed out the phone system, they turned to the growing market of electric streetcars. And these really heavy electric streetcars would push and pull a ton of power. But by using the lead acid battery to float on those lines and maintain a consistent current, you could run those streetcars and buffer against the dynamo that's able to then run steadily.
So in both cases, on the phone line and on the streetcar line, the battery sits in the middle and keeps the power steady. It's acting as a buffer. And the grid wasn't originally built with any buffer. Every watt had to be made the moment someone used it. And most of the grid still works that way today. And so this is a good moment to pause and thank our presenting sponsor, Base Power, because BASE is putting that buffer into the grid. Without any buffer, you get two main problems. The first is that when a line goes down, your house goes dark, you have no backup power.
And the second is that the entire system, the entire grid, has to be built for the worst hour of the year. That hottest afternoon when every air conditioner is running and every EV is being plugged into charge. And we all have to pay for all the poles, wires and transformers size for that worst hour of the year.
But a battery helps with both. It charges when power is cheap and plentiful, and discharges when power is expensive or when your line goes down. If you put batteries in enough homes, then the system doesn't have to be built as big, which brings down the bills for everyone. So if you were to rebuild the grid today, what would you do? You would probably invert the topography of the grid, because with batteries, you could build a business model that encourages you to deploy as much of this buffer as possible and orchestrate them to improve the entire system.
This would meet the moment of today and the challenges of affordability and resilience. And that's what Base Power does. Base is a technology driven power company. They partner with utilities to deploy batteries in people's homes to deliver cost effective, dispatchable capacity and provide households with backup power during outages. They're building a network of batteries in American homes that protects families from outages and strengthens the grid around them. They design, manufacture and install batteries, every system themselves.
And so if this sounds like a problem you want to go work on, BASE is hiring. BASE is looking for great engineers, operators, creatives, and builders. If that feels like you, head over to basepowercompany.com careers and tell them the Stepchange team sent you,
okay, back to those streetcars pulling power from batteries. You start to wonder, could we get batteries to power our transport altogether?
Could we get electric vehicles?
But this is the 1800s.
Turns out there's a lot of interest because let's go to a large American city at the turn of the century. These are horse driven cities. New York around 1890 has about 150,000 horses. That might sound cute, but then think about what those horses are giving off.
Wait, I love, I love farms. I love horses. 150,000 horses. Just chilling.
Well, every day each of those horses may be dropping 22 pounds of manure.
Oh,
you know, you do the math. And that's about a half million tons a year of manure. Not to mention maybe 100 million gallons of urine. If you took that manure and spread it over Central park, that's about 10 inches deep in manure. Or 150 Olympic swimming pools of urine.
Okay, okay, now I'm getting too much imagery.
Well, at this time you also have the rise in bicycle manufacturing, which starts to set up factories that can make light steel vehicles in some quantity. And you know, class of buyers who have more money for personal transport, who want to show up to the theater in their nice carriages and they start organizing lobby to have more paved smooth roads to make the city into a nice place. This era is the first beginnings of motor vehicles. And it was not clear at all at the time who was going to win this three horse race, no pun intended.
The first really were people building steam engine cars. Then you had gasoline engines and the lead acid batteries all neck and neck. And as soon as we had those production lead acid batteries, the EV group was on. In the next 15 to 20 years is something to behold in Paris, a tricycle hooked up driving 12km an hour in 1881. A few years later in Germany, the Flocken Electrowagen, which is my favorite named car in this story, is perhaps the first production EV in history. It does nine miles an hour on about one horsepower.
Now back in the US a Des Moines buggy with a 50 mile range and it's a sensation at the Chicago World's Fair.
And so you've got the company that had built the electric streetcar, start looking at the motorcar. And they introduced the Electro Bat, which may be the second best name. And this thing is a beast, man. It is 4,000 pounds. About a third of it are batteries. And it could go a hundred miles if you drive it gingerly on steel tires so it can support its weight. But they improve. The Electro Bat 2 comes out, it's two thirds of the weight. You start to get the electric taxi fleets that go into service with a hundred of them going into New York City right at the turn of the 20th century.
And just like today's EVs you have instant torque and fun. Cocktail party Fact. May of 1899. Cab driver Jacob German becomes the first motorist arrested for speeding doing 12 miles an hour down Lexington Avenue.
A little bit more of a morbid fact about this is that it's an electric cab that kills the first pedestrian in American history.
And so you've got all of these batteries powering a motorized car revolution. Now if EVs actually want to win this race against a gas car, you've got to be able to go the distance. The Electrobat company takes this on. They build out a massive set of overhead cranes that can lift out the thousands of pounds of batteries and swap them back in in about three minutes.
This is absolutely wild. You're telling me that in 1900 we had battery swapping stations for EVs in New York? Part of it is that in cities it's the perfect market for this. Right? It looked like an obvious answer. You had high society customers that didn't want to deal with the cranking start of a car. That was really hard. They didn't want to deal with the smoke and the noise. They're tired of the horse poop. And of course the electric utilities that were just birthed at that time were excited about this. A vehicle that's sitting there, plugged in, charging overnight wasn't going to compete with their daylight customers.
And so our protagonist from the Grid episode, Samuel Insull of Chicago Edison, opens charging stations and gives them a discount for off peak rates. Back in 1898 we were doing time of use rates, man, it's like the first Tesla superchargers of the time. And so to understand this moment, you have to appreciate that cars are a very rare luxury good. If you look at the 1900 census, it counts the cars by type. There are only around 4,000 cars sold. But there are more EVs then internal combustion engine cars sold that year back in 1900.
Are the EVs going to win the race?
Are they going to win? I don't know. I'm on the edge of my seat. What happens in the century? Well, let's also look at another layer of what's going on. This is the era of trusts and monopolies, right? This is when the game Monopoly comes out of kind of in reaction to this era. And so the battery suppliers to this blowing up EV industry, the main battery supplier is called Electric Storage Battery Company of Philadelphia. They buy out all the patents from all the other companies from ge, from Edison, so they have a full monopoly on battery production.
That same group on the other side merges all the taxi players and all the manufacturers into the Electric Vehicle Company, attempting to kind of own all sides of this business.
Vertical integration at its finest.
That's right. But unfortunately they're clumsy. The Electric Vehicle Company gets caught up in a fraudulent loan and by 1907, they go bankrupt. Meanwhile, Edison is furious that one company has locked up this crucial rechargeable battery technology. And he sets out to go invent an even better battery. He spends the next decade on it and lands on a nickel iron based cell. He even adds a little lithium and finds it that it gives him more power without quite understanding why that works. But unfortunately his battery comes out a lot more expensive than lead acid.
And this is all against the backdrop of a very real, much cheaper alternative that's starting to pick up steam in the race, the internal combustion engine.
So you got this three car race between your EVs, your internal combustion engines and your steam engine. And what happens is the gas car pulls ahead. And so Whereas in the 1900s a few hundred more EVs were sold than gas cars, by 1910, nearly all of the half million cars sold in America were gasoline. It came down to being very simple. Most of the roads were dirt roads on places that didn't have electricity, whereas every corner store was carrying gasoline and kerosene. And so your fuel was readily available. The nail in the coffin is probably the cost, right?
The Model t launches at $850. It soon falls to $350. Meanwhile, the EV is costing north of $3,000. So it's forced to retreat up into an upmarket product. And it becomes the car with plush interiors. It's clean, it's silent, it doesn't have this terrible hand crank that makes your wrist hurt. And they find the market niche in wealthy urban women.
The electric that meets the every need of the society woman and emblematic of this, Clara Ford. Henry Ford's wife, refuses to drive an internal combustion engine car during this whole period. She loves her Detroit Electric that has that Edison improved battery as an option. And she drove this car into the 30s.
I do wonder what those dinnertime conversations were. And see a Ford and Edison, they give it one more go to prototype a Model T with a nickel iron cell. But they just can't get it there. There's no electric car that can compete with gas on economics. And so that is how the story ends for now.
While this decimated the electric vehicle market, you would think it would bring down the battery market too. But just exactly the Opposite happened, going from 4,000 cars to half a million cars of that decade. Well, those half million cars had a fundamental user experience flaw. They all had to be started by hand. You had this crank that you had to put in front of the car to start it. You'd set the spark, you walk to the front, you turn the crank. If the engine fires backwards, that crank spins into your arm or your face.
It happened often enough. The doctors have a name for the broken form, the chauffeur's fracture.
This is such a problem, and it's pervasive to the point where a friend of the head of Cadillac stops on the bridge to help a woman crank her car. He turns the crank, it snaps, hits him back in the jaw, and he ends up dying in Detroit Hospital of pneumonia a few days later. And this leads Henry Leland, the head of Cadillac, to put his engineers onto the problem of how do we get rid of the hand crank?
And so he goes to one Charles Kettering, who's an engineer who had spent years at National Cash Register or ncr, building an electric motor to open a registered drawer. And there's a parallel problem here, powering a motor that only has to run for a few seconds. And he takes that same design and spins it out into his own firm to apply to an engine. He calls this firm Delco. This starts to work. He's created the self starter, where a battery powers a motor to actually turn over the engine, and you can just start it with the push of a button.
So Leland, head of Cadillac, loves the solution. Orders 12,000 of them that November. The 1912 Cadillac is the first vehicle to ship with electric starting, has lighting and ignition, all standard equipment. And it runs on four six volt lead acid batteries.
And the rest of the industry just follows. And if there was any lingering doubt in the EV story, this puts a nail in the coffin, because that last advantage of being able to start the car without physical effort is gone. And so now the most widespread use of batteries is not powering the car, it's enabling it to start power. The lights, eventually turn signals, windshield wipers, and the radios.
And this is a dramatic growing market. So, yes, you no longer have the EV market, but you're inside of every other car that's going on, on the road up through to today. The next thing Kettering looked at was another market that was missing electricity. He looked at all the rural farms, and mind you, this is before the Rural Electrification act, so most farms had no electrical source. And so he started to package up a product that combined A battery, an engine and a generator to charge that battery that could run early lighting inside of farms.
And this thing sold millions of units. So at this point, we had the lead acid market booming. Between these Delco light products, the starter battery, Telco, and smoothing out the grid, where does the lead actually come from? Where does the sulfur actually come from? What are the human implications of that? And what is the system that we've created out of that over the last century? And so lead has primarily come from this old Missouri lead belt. It was actually generally a co product or a byproduct of silver mining and zinc mining that was happening.
The volume of lead that was available in the early days was set by those prices, not by the battery demand. The sulfur story is a little bit darker. For much of the early history here, 95% of the world's sulfur was supplied by Sicily. It was mined by hand under conditions that were notoriously bad, primarily by this group of mining boys called Carusi. Booker T. Washington visited once and said that it was about the nearest thing to hell that is conceivable. And part of this was that these mining boys were essentially given us property to the owners of the mines and reminding the worst possible working conditions.
They were often recruited as young as 5 to 7 years of age. And once then they lived their whole lives in the mines, around the mines, and had essentially zero freedom. Now, as demand for sulfur grew, we fortunately found another way to get it out that did not involve this terrible mining practice in the U.S. we've found that if we injected superheated water in and around a region of Louisiana, you'd be able to melt the sulfur out and pump it out. And that became the dominant source of sulfur going forward.
But this battery market is booming and it's compulsory in so many products. You're having millions and millions of these sold every year. It can be recharged, but it'll ultimately die after one to two years. But you can simply melt it down and reform that battery and sell it back to the market just as new. And so this is actually what drives the lead acid battery to become ultimately the most recycled product on earth.
During this time, lead was being used in all kinds of things. Unfortunately, lead paint, you had lead pipes, you had covering on cables, you had insecticide, and of course, leaded gasoline that was all consumed lead. Unlike those products, the car battery was different. You had 18 pounds of lead in a case, and after two years it was dead. And so instead of thinking of lead acid batteries as consumables, people Started thinking about the lead inside of those batteries as essentially a loan of lead to that particular battery.
And as the market boomed, so did the potential supply of recyclable lead. You take out the dead batteries, you'd go melt them down in and around a near your city and return it back into another battery. This was all happening with no legal construct or requirement or even deposit mechanism. And it was simply the price of lead. By the mid-1960s, the recycling rate went up as high as 97% of the lead inside of batteries. We've built this essentially closed loop recycling market with no legal necessity. What could be bad about that?
Unfortunately, with lead, it's an ugly, ugly story because the way you recycle the lead is by burning it down, all parts of it. And it is absolutely terrible for health. As early as the 1930s at Johns Hopkins University, you had a seven year old girl admitted with a sudden onset of convulsions, followed a few months later by a 10 year old boy, followed a few months later by 40 more cases of lead poisoning. And we very quickly found that these cases of poisoning were primarily amongst black families that were living in and around these recycling centers.
For the next many decades. All of the research on whether lead was safe was being paid for by the company selling it. And one scientist hired by GM named Kehoe came up with a doctrine that became accepted belief, and he essentially espoused that lead occurs naturally. So for the longest time, we never questioned and never investigated the causes of all these tragedies, Primarily in urban environments amongst black and brown families. Eventually the research does catch up. We look into the causes of all this poisoning, find out it's lead, and ban leaded gasoline and leaded paint in the 70s.
And that worked phenomenally well. We've started to take lead out of the environment, kids. Blood level drops lead falls 80% in the late 70s to the 90s. And of course the rest of the policy starts to look at the lead batteries as a hazardous waste. It's no longer you can just go smelt them in your backyard. That near a hundred percent rate drops to 60% in the early 80s. And all of a sudden you're putting batteries in the landfill.
And so the batteries in the landfill now become a state problem. So we ban them from the landfills and we create a system where the retailer has to take the old one back and refund a deposit when it comes in. Exide pays Kmart$2 a battery. So the truck that delivers the new ones collects the dead ones on the way out. This drives the market such that recycling rate returns back to that 97% we talked about. But the pernicious problem of lead didn't go away. We just exported them. Because now we're importing lead batteries from countries that don't have the safeguards around proper manufacturing and proper recycling.
Those batteries are broken down by hand, smelted in the open. And the impact of this is astounding. One in three children worldwide have some form of lead poisoning. That's 800 million kids, with most of them concentrated in these developing countries that have no controls where we're exporting our lead batteries out to. And so yes, we are maintaining a high recycling rate, but at a very, very high cost.
We've achieved this closed loop system, but it's for this very dangerous material. And then we've exported all these externalities. The stats on this is that this lead poisoning leads to three and a half million deaths per year.
Wow. And that's the reality of the lead acid battery. It's on the one hand, the first rechargeable battery that could stay charged and deliver enough power to catalyze applications from the telephone to submarines, to every car on the road today, including EVs. It needs no management system, works at all temperatures and hopefully can be one day safely recycled.
We have safe ways to recycle lead. Let's be clear. It's an economic, global choice that this is the state of things.
That's right. It's not the first time we've seen seen this with a commodity, and it's not going to be the last time in this story that we see horrific global impacts to the inputs needed to power our economy.
Disposables1909–1991
So that's the story of lead acid. The first battery you could recharge, still in nearly every car and still poisoning people wherever it's recycled, poorly. It's now time to move to the next chapter of our story. We need to return to the disposable battery and how those early dry cells that we left powering radios in the 1920s have ended up in every kitchen drawer. Those AA's, AAA's and 9 volt batteries, what was the story of how those evolved over the last century? Today, for context, 40 billion of those types of batteries are made per year.
That's about 5 of the disposable batteries per person on earth annually. And almost all of Those are the AA's and AAA's that we're familiar with in this era. What ramped up from radios was really about to transform. To go from those 300 million batteries a year to the tens of billion today. So let's go back to what were those? Those were these what we call dry cells, but they were really like pasty cells where all of them were made with the zinc carbon chemistry. A zinc anode, which was actually the outside can, was the negative end.
And the cathode was a mix of manganese dioxide with a black graphite carbon. This was packed against a central rod that acts as the current collector. And in this era is when the standards start to come in both on sizing and also performance. So you had the D cells and the C cells that were designed around really the early flashlight tubes. And as those tubes got smaller, you wanted smaller cells. You have the AA that we're so familiar with, that size and standard was set in 1907 for the first set of what they called pocket lights or pen lights.
But there was still this problem of standardization of quality. What voltage were you going to get out of this thing? What longevity were you going to get out of this thing? What was the durability? And the army was starting to buy a lot of these things. They wanted to know what they were buying. And so very quickly there was a fourth standardization. And this was the beginning where the marketing shifted less about what the quality of your aura was and started to become about your brand.
And this specifications and standardizations came just in time for World War II to absolutely turbocharge to production use of these dry cells. You could throw a couple of them in and fire a bazooka. You could put some in your backpack, walkie talkie, and be able to communicate with the rest of your infantry. The production for military doubles to a billion and a half cells by the middle of the war. And that means that at home batteries are being rationed. But once these batteries get to war, the cells face a test that they had not faced in quality testing beforehand.
When the batteries go into 700 different pieces of equipment and have to be shipped across the Pacific Rim, they're in an entirely new environment. So that zinc can already self discharges slowly in the acidic paste, even when nothing is switched on. But that discharge roughly doubles with every 10 degrees of warmth. The cells aren't airtight either, right. That seal is a wax with pinched over cardboard jacket, which is okay for a hardware store in Ohio, but you put that in the humidity of the South Pacific and the cells start to leak and short.
And on top of that you add travel time. So the cell leaves a Cleveland factory, which usually gets shipped across the country and instead is arriving at the bases, months later, dead on arrival. So the batteries are being used on the order of billions through the war, but they're also leaving our troops stranded. So in 1942, inventor Samuel Ruben changes all three parts at once. For that electron taker, the cathode, he decides to use a mercuric oxide, a heavy, stable compound that can hold a lot of charge in a very small amount of space.
Then for that in between electrolyzer, he uses a potassium hydroxide, the lye, which is an alkali rather than an acid. It carries charge better, works in different temperatures, and is where the word alkaline comes from. Finally, he takes the zinc as an anode out of the roll of the container and makes it a separate piece. So now he can build an airtight steel can. Nothing getting in, nothing getting out.
And this battery is an immense leap. I think it's something like four to seven times the energy of the cells that came before it. And the durability jump, right. Humidity cannot touch it. The army views this as a key war asset. It's a key invention, so they go and classify it. And Ruben teams up with Mallory of Indianapolis and Rayovac to go produce a million cells a day to supply the army. They would later form a consumer company out of this durable cell battery, or a Duracell. Now, let's notice what Ruben used for the cathode.
This is the first time that mercury goes into a battery in quantity. In this cell, mercury is the main ingredient. It's most of the weight of the cathode of that positive side, and that makes it a superb battery with all of this storage energy. It also makes it an extremely dangerous battery to manufacture. You end up with terrible stories of mercury poisoning when people are producing these things. Now, after the war, the industry sees this as the design to keep and go forward, but we have to lose the mercury. It's fundamentally just too expensive.
But let's keep the steel can, let's keep the alkaline electrolyte, let's keep that stable cathode and find a different material. Let's go back to manganese dioxide. And so the natural ore that was being used before was good enough for a leaky dry cell, but no longer in the sealed alkaline one, where any impurity is going to cause some gasification and going to cause the can to start to fill up with gas. And so the industry starts making purified manganese via electrolysis. Now, this takes an immense amount of energy, about 20 units of electricity for every one in the finished cell.
But it produces a phenomenal battery that no longer needs an immense amount of mercury that's expensive inside of it. They moved this powdered zinc. But powdered zinc in an alkaline has a problem, right?
That's right. You get this hydrogen gas that we talked about earlier coming off of this, which makes the cell very dangerous. So we need something to stop the fizzing, stop that production of gas. And so what Ruben ends up doing is bringing back just a dash of mercury to stop the powdered zinc from giving off that hydrogen gas and bursting the cell. So you've got mercury coming back into the alkaline cell no longer as the made ingredient, but as about 1% of the cell's weight as an additive to make this shelf ready.
Long lasting disposable battery work in every use case you could want. And this becomes the composition of every alkaline sold for nearly the next 30 years.
I okay, so we've exited the war, we figured out this chemistry, and now the business is ready to scale. This is the post war boom time. So Americans are starting to buy cameras and kitchen clocks and flashlights, and these alkaline batteries become the source behind all of it. And business booms. Now back to the marketing, because this becomes the competition ground. The Mallory Company names those cells Duracell. In 1964, Union Carbide says they need a differentiated brand for their alkaline production. So instead of going by Eveready, they come up with Energizer in 1980.
And now Duracell runs a famous campaign in the early 70s saying these batteries help your toys last longer. And it's this competition of toy bunnies drumming. And a decade later, Energizer responds with that same ad running. But the Energizer Bunny outlasts them all. And so this battle of the bunnies, we're no longer talking about chemistry or where the ore is mined. We're talking about which one's going to keep the bunny lasting longer.
It has to be a marketing game because every cell had to meet the same federal standard. And so you've essentially normalized the actual product. And everything's got to be sold on the vibes. And as we enter the 1980s, this is where the dance party really starts to take off. I love this part of the story because I can see myself in my bedroom in the 80s, right? Sony releases the Sony Walkman, a cassette player with headphones. It runs on two double A cells and it just eats them.
And the products that hit. Sony sells 10 million Walkmans in five years. At the end of the decade, 1989, Nintendo releases the Game Boy. That thing's eaten through batteries. So this is the beginnings, the real rise of consumer electronics that are just consuming piles and piles of alkaline batteries. Now let's go back and remember that every one of those cells has mercury in it. And with the rise of the consumption of these batteries, people are starting to realize that the mercury might be a problem. Part of it is that the American households are just throwing away more trash in general, and the country is starting to close landfills and build incinerators, realizing that we're going to go burn trash, like, what is that going to do to the air?
Minnesota in early 1990 passes a law. It capsule the mercury in a cell at 0.025% of the alkaline cell weight. So the actual chemical composition of the product has to change in order to comply with this law. If we removed impurities from that zinc powder and we were able to grind up the mercury that we did put in more and more, finally we're able to solve that hydrogen gas problem. Mercury in American cells drops by 98%.
This raised the question during our research of like, okay, if the mercury's gone, should I really be recycling my batteries? Well, the answer's a bit unfortunate. 97% of the environmental cost of the alkaline battery comes from the making of it. It's in the refining of the materials to that high, high level of purity to make it function so well. And most recycling in this country requires a couple thousand miles to ship it around. And what you end up with is very low grade outputs. And so for states that require it by law, California, Vermont, yes, you should.
The real fix around this question of should you recycle? What to do with your alkaline batteries is buy fewer. But the disposable battery won because it was easy, it was portable, it gave you the power you needed. And we bought it by the billions.
We're still buying it by the billions.
Yeah.
And as this consumer electronics market developed, of course there's a desire for batteries that you could use in your more powerful devices. Well, let's look back at our periodic table, and there we see our friend lithium in that upper left hand corner. And so if you use lithium to make a battery cell, it gives about 3 volts against alkalines, 1 1/2, twice the voltage in the same size, and it can have a shelf life of 10 years or more. And it works phenomenally well even if it's cold. And so in the 70s, we start developing these premium lithium cells and we start using them in premium applications.
One of those premium applications sits right inside your body. Through the 1960s, the pacemaker that keeps the hearts running for patients runs on the same mercury cells as a hearing aid, and they fail just like a hearing aid does after about two years. So patients with pacemakers at this time had to live on a schedule of surgeries driven by the life of the battery. So then in the early 70s, a Baltimore firm patents a solid state lithium iodide cell, which means no liquid at all, nothing to leak, nothing to gas, and battery life goes from two years to 10 years.
And lithium's first job was to keep that heart beating and those surgeries down. The second place you find lithium at this time is in your watch, right? Panasonic develops a lithium coin cell, and then Sanyo makes an even cheaper one. And, and this coin cell goes into every watch, calculator, camera and car key since then. And it's still about 80% of all lithium disposable sold today.
These are those coin sized cell that your airtags use. Watches use
the coin
cell, the coin cell.
And so lithium comes into this world as a disposable, first in the pacemaker, then in the watches and radios and camcorders. And all of this is why lithium sounded like a premium word and carries this connotation of being a high performance battery. Now, like we saw earlier in the story, the battery is doing such a good job that people start to think about how it can do more and perhaps how we can recharge it.
But one more thing has to happen before anyone can recharge it. And it starts with who owns the technology. By the early 1980s, the American battery shelf really is dominated by this one company, Union Carbide, which owns the consumer brands Eveready and Energizer, but also owns other chemical projects. Notably, they also have a joint venture that's helping Sony manufacture batteries in Japan. Well, in the mid-80s, a terrible accident happened unrelated to their battery business. A pestide plant in Bhopal in India leaks gas over half a million people in the community.
This accident is considered the worst industrial accident in human history. Thousands die and many more thousands are badly injured. The lawsuits and collapsing share price lead to this crumbling business that has to sell off assets to raise cash to survive. It sells off the main disposable business to Ralston Purina. Yes, the Purina dog food brand that was trying to find out other products that people like to buy as regularly as they buy their dog food and sell batteries. But notably, Sony swoops in and buys out the rest of that joint venture.
It wants full control of those factories because it has some big plans of what it wants to do in the energy storage market. They renamed that recombined business Sony Energytec. What's interesting about this turning point is from some accounts on the Sony side, Sony wanted this joint venture to go more and more into studying lithium and other things that they could do with it, including rechargeable lithium. Union Carbide, who own half the jv, was supposedly slowing them down. And so this moment in history, and in part because of this terrible gas plant accident, leads to Sony consolidating their own capability in their hands.
And some have said that this has foreshadowed the Japanese rise and ability to run first at lithium ion cells, as we'll get to in our next section.
Lithium, Lab to Laptop1966–2019
So that concludes our story on the disposal batteries, all those Energizers and Duracells. And now it's time for the chapter on the story of the lithium ion cell and how the lithium ion cell went from a lab bench to inside all of our laptops and phones. So let's drop back in to the early 1970s. And the workhorses of the rechargeable battery are still this amazing, big, complicated lead acid battery and nickel cadmium. We know how to make them. We know exactly what they can do. But if you want to carry more energy without carrying more weight, you got to do something different.
And, and it comes back to the chemistry and that top left corner of the periodic table that Ben mentioned earlier. Lithium is very tempting to achieve. More power with less weight. It's the lightest metal there is. Pair it with the right materials, and you can get a much higher voltage, which means a lot more energy out of a much smaller package. The problem with lithium is it's also super reactive and very easily catches fire. That's why it doesn't naturally occur as a pure metal. Making a lithium ion battery that works once is one challenge.
Making it work over and over again is an entirely different challenge. And so now we're going to tell the amazing story of the lithium ion battery. This is the battery that has completely transformed our ability to power almost all of our personal devices, our E bikes, our cars, and now the grid. It really is the reason we're doing this episode. So to pull off the amazing new invention of lithium ion batteries, we we're going to traverse roughly 20 years of people trying to solve four interrelated problems. One, find the lithium a home.
It can move in and out of a kind of sponge that soaks it up and gives it back. That's what makes it rechargeable. Two, make that sponge stable and raise the voltage. Three, get the lithium metal out, because that metal is what catches fire. And four, build a factory that can make millions of cells safely and cheaply. Now, no two of these breakthroughs happen in the same place, and the scientists behind them make very little money from their progress. Interestingly enough, we need to start our story with a car company, an oil company, and a little bit of chemistry.
So it's 1966 in Dearborn, Michigan, and two Ford researchers are playing around with different battery chemistries, and they build a cell that absolutely reverses the traditional battery textbook. Until then, everyone had assumed that reactions that matter happen on the surface of an electrode, that metal surface. But a small group of scientists were now finding that ions can move around inside of a solid crystal almost as freely as those inside of a liquid. Well, one of the people who is watching this research is a young English chemist who's working out of Stanford, Stan Whittingham.
And his primary goal of his research is to measure how fast ions are moving inside of the ceramic electrolyte. Surprisingly, an oil company comes calling in 1972, Exxon is staffing up its research and engineering group. It has aspirations to be a sort of Bell Labs of the energy business. And so they hire Stan Whittingham away from Stanford. He's there in his early 30s, and his job is to come and do fundamental research. There's no direct product goal in mind yet. And he notices an interesting result. You can inject ions into a compound, and that they'll start being able to hold those ions in place.
Instead of it being a reaction that changes the material, it actually is more like holding water in a sponge.
This is such a big deal because every battery up to this point worked by reacting. It turned chemical energy into electrical energy, consuming the materials in the process of the reaction. And what Whittingham found absolutely reverses the way a traditional battery works, because nothing is getting consumed in the reaction. Ions are just moving from a higher energy state to a lower energy state. Think of this crystal like a parking garage. You've got layers, and you've got empty space between the layers. The ions drive in and they park.
And when you charge it back up, they drive right back out. The building itself never changes. The structure remains. And because you're not consuming anything, there's nothing to wear out. So these ions can drive in and out and in and out thousands of times. And that's what gives us this fundamental high energy rechargeability.
And this has a name that we mentioned back during our batteries 101 at the beginning of the episode. It's called intercalation. Fun fact. The word intercalation comes from the calendar. An intercalary day is a day you insert into a year that already exists, that structure that's already there. Like a Leap Day, February 29, you're slipping something into a structure without having to rebuild the structure. An intercalation is an immense discovery. This is foundational.
And it's interesting because when he does this, it runs at about two and a half volts, which is nearly double the existing nickel cadmium cell. And so this discovery comes at a great time. He figures this out in the lab, and less than a year later, the oil crisis hits. Crude oil goes from $3 to $12 a barrel. And Exxon, in all of its brilliance, decides that it's no longer just an oil company. It wants to be an energy company. And it invests essentially an unlimited amount of money into anything that's not petroleum, including batteries and electric cars.
And so Whittingham spins up the advanced battery project, gets an entire development plant, and Exxon is now in the battery business. This seems great. And hey, Exxon's going to become a really great steward of electrification from now on, right? Like, there's nothing that's going to stop them from this conviction that they should invest in batteries.
They're going to be up there with beyond petroleum, I think. And all of this is built on the presumption that we kind of hit peak oil and that we need to diversify. The thing is that presumption starts to drop out.
This scientific program is in reaction to the price, not any fundamental belief under this. But by the end of that decade, the recession starts to hit, the oil price breaks, and suddenly nobody needs a battery project anymore. Exxon completely divests from this, and then the administration doubles down. Reagan's budget cuts, cut a ton of solar programs and energy conservation programs, and your labs scattered across the country just lose funding overnight.
I think the 1984 press report says Exxon rededicates itself to oil.
Wow, wonderful.
So there's one product that does spin out of this, right, which is the button sized cell that I think a Swiss watch company puts in, combined with the solar cell to build the perpetual watch, this watch that kind of keeps topping itself up. And Exxon says, we're Going to shut down our own manufacturing and license this out to other folks.
Through all of these ups and downs, the amazing discovery of intercalation and the rechargeable lithium ion battery has actually turned in to a product.
So let's go up to our friends up north in Canada. Important company Moli Energy is formed to try and build rechargeable batteries and sell them at scale. There's a real wireless market forming. Go back to 1984. This is Motorola selling the first handheld wireless cell phone. It's like a shoebox sized thing, weighs two and a half pounds, costing $4,000. And most of what you're carrying around is battery. And so you have this customer wanting a lighter, more energy dense, better battery. Well, there's a physics professor at the University of British Columbia and he hears about Exxon's cell developing throughout the 70s.
And Moli Energy is building a cousin of Exxon's battery design. Same basic idea, a slab of pure lithium metal on one side. What makes them interesting is that they're the first company to try and manufacture a rechargeable lithium battery at scale. The anode is an ultra thin lithium metal foil. And this is very hard to work with. Someone's quote is saying is handling lithium foil is like handling a wet lasagna noodle. And we're the first to try and manufacture that at any scale.
Being the first ever in manufacturing is really interesting because today to set up a lithium ion plant, you can call up a Japanese or Chinese equipment maker and say, I need a winder and it'll get shipped to you. They were the first ones using winding machines at speed.
And so the process, the machine improvements are just as much part of what needs to happen. We think about manufacturing as the chemistry. And oftentimes the first people trying to manufacture this stuff are going to flail around like a wet lasagna noodle. But there's so much demand for this stuff goes on sale and it sells, most of it actually goes to Japan, right where the consumer electronics boom is happening into NEC laptops and NTT mobile phones. The problem is it had not been out in the field very long before you're sending it out into the world with consumers.
In summer 1989, the thing that everyone's been afraid of actually happens. An entity phone with a Moli battery cell catches fire and injures the person holding it. NGT goes and recalls 10,000 phones. Moli stops production for months and it's a crisis.
Now, to be fair, Moli Energy had done a tremendous amount of testing on these Cells. But they were under manufacturing deadlines, and testing can be a slow, tedious process. It's very hard to test something on all its different failure rates, especially once you have users using them in very, very different ways.
Just to explain the failure mode, what happens is in this shallow cycling that people do on their phones, where it's not necessarily going down and cycling once a day, they're plugging in, taking off, plugging in again, that grows this high surface lithium foil. The lithium ions are returning and puncturing through the separator, causing the short that then kicks off the thermal runaway that we're all so afraid of. And this was this persistent problem anytime that you have lithium metal as your anode.
So what happens when a battery company has a fire and has to recall phones? They run out of money. Their lender calls for their $20 million loan, and within 48 hours, you have the first rechargeable lithium factory on Earth, sold this time to Japanese buyers.
And so this teed up a bunch of room for improvement. Back to the labs.
And so the man we're about to meet stands at the center of so much of the innovation in physics and chemistry around lithium ion batteries. He and his lab are going to define the next major set of innovations and ultimately win the Nobel Prize. This man is John Goodenough. He has a wild and difficult educational journey, finds it very hard to learn to read, but somehow ends up studying physics. After World War II, under the infamous Fermi, his expertise becomes how electrons and ions move inside of metal oxides, which is perfect for this problem we're talking about, of the layered crystal sponge cathode structure that's holding these lithium ions.
He spends 24 years in an MIT lab. But by the mid-70s, the energy crisis has taken over the world, and Goodenough wants to be a part of it. He ends up moving to Oxford to run a chemistry lab, having only taken a couple undergraduate courses in chemistry in his entire life.
So he gets to Oxford and he wants to work on the energy problem. And he's excited by energy storage. And he's been following Winnie Nim's work from the Exxon lab. And he has a strong conviction that there's gotta be a better sponge on that side to hold the lithium ions that are moving in and out. And he knows that, in particular, metal oxides are gonna do better than the metal sulfides that Whittingham was using. And so he pushes his lab and staff hard. He goes out to make chromium cobalt, a nickel version of these lithium metal oxides and measure carefully how far they can push them before the cathode becomes unstable.
And they find that cobalt does the best. About half the lithium can come out before the layers of the crystal start to collapse and the sponge kind of breaks down. And it also gives you 4 volts against the 2.4 volts that Whittingham cell was giving. So it's both more stable and a higher voltage. They published this seminal paper in 1980.
Now, this 4v ends up being part of the headline. But the real invention here happens in how the cell is assembled. Because up until now, every battery before this was built fully charged, which means you had to put reactive lithium metal into the device. But now with this cobalt cathode, Goodenough's cell begins discharged. And so it just becomes much easier to start to manufacture this into a real product and begin to see how you could build it at scale. It doesn't stop the fires on its own, but the lithium can now come from the cathode.
So the anode doesn't have to be that tricky lithium metal anymore. And so someone can now revisit the anode and get rid of. Of the lithium metal.
Sony here is in a bit of the right place, right time, with the right assets. They have this immense need. They're becoming a consumer electronics giant. They were getting tired of the nickel cadmium. It's heavy, it's toxic. And Japan was putting pressure on them to remove mercury from all the disposable cells. Now, remember, Sony had just bought out Union Carbide from that joint venture in the mid-80s. And so now they have their own battery fabric. And they decide to go all in on trying to figure out can they mass manufacture rechargeable lithium ion batteries.
And so how are they going to get their cells out of this whole lithium metal anode problem that everyone else has been hitting against? That Moli cell just exploded a phone on.
Well, as happens with many problems, it comes from an unsuspecting corner. Akira Yoshino is an engineer working at a petrochemical company in Japan, and he's trying to figure out what conductive plastics can serve as a battery electrode. But he's. He's not getting anywhere with his research. He then reads Goodenough's paper on the cobalt oxide, and he realizes something. If the cathode is already arriving with the lithium inside it, then all the anode has to do is accept the lithium and give it back. It doesn't actually have to supply anything.
It doesn't have to be lithium. It can be something cheap, something stable, something that has room to layer inside of it, such as carbon. And so what Yoshino ends up doing is using petroleum coke, a high purity carbon, and he files a patent for the coke anode cell. And how do you know it works? Well, they do the drop test. They drop a massive iron weight on a lithium metal battery and sets it afire. Does the same test on the coke anode cell and nothing happens.
And Sony Energytec, that company that came out of that recombined Sony entity, signs an agreement and gets exclusive access to Yoshino's working prototype. And what follows from there is then four years of engineering work to move into mass production in the early 90s. And there's one big marketing decision before they ship it. What should we call this thing? Right, there's all kinds of chemistry in here. There's carbon, there's cobalt, there's electrolyte, there's lithium in there. Well, let's go back. Remember those premium disposable cells, Those were called lithium.
And people know that that means high energy and high quality and high price. So let's call these things lithium ion cells. And so Sony releases the first lithium ion cells to consumers as part of its Handycam product. At 3.6 volts, it's the highest density rechargeable that's ever been on sale.
One sad twist to the story is Goodenough never met any of the Sony scientists that commercialized his cathode. He had no idea this was being worked on until he read about it in the news alongside everyone else. It could have been Exxon, but it wasn't.
We could be here driving our rechargeable Exxon cars.
What Japan did, and in this case Sony first was put together their engineering expertise and ability to produce batteries at scale from their decade of of consumer electronics experience to get the lithium ion battery into that Sony camcorder.
So here we are in Japan and they have the factory lines set up from 30 years making sealed cans for alkaline nickel, cadmium, and those disposable lithium cells. And so they're set up for these cylindrical cells. And the core manufacturing process is to make these long sheets that are essentially the three layers, the anode, the cathode, and a separator in between with an electrolyte paste. And they're rolling this up to stack in the cylindrical cells and connecting with two tabs to the case. Fun industry fact. Everyone in the industry calls this design the jelly roll because it looks like you've created these layers and rolled it up like a jelly roll.
Maybe that's where the artist Jelly Roll got his name from.
I think he was studying the lithium ion process.
He must have been. He has a great song on the soundtrack for the goat movie that my son loves. The jelly roll is not easy, whether you're wrapping or you're making batteries. So the lead acid industry is incredibly forgiving. But in the lithium world, you're operating at a sub micron precision. So the cells coming off these lines are famously named 18650. It's named 18650 simply for the dimensions of it. 18 millimeters across and 65 long. The size of that is what's interesting. It's not a double A, it's not a C cell.
The size of the 18650 that Sony manufactures is what fit nicely in the back of a Sony camcorder. And then Sony takes the same size and reuses it for laptops and sells it to everyone. By the early 2000s, this is essentially the only lithium ion cell being made at real volume. And it's simply because the camcorders design was set that way.
And competitors start to pile in, almost all of them Japanese. Sanyo comes back, Panasonic starts to roll out, and here we go.
And they own the decade because Korea doesn't start mass production with LG until the end of the 1990s. Samsung follows and China is still importing all its cells. So think of the 90s as the decade of Japan for making lithium ion cells at tremendous volume.
And this pushes the consumer electronics industry forward, especially the mobile industry. In 1997, there are more than 120 million wireless subscribers worldwide, and the number is doubling year over year. The Economist in 2002 says that if you compare the new handset to what those first car phones look like, there's this 99% weight reduction that's been achieved mostly because of battery technology improvements. And the same thing's happening in laptops. They're all transitioning from early nickel cadmium and nickel metal hydride to lithium ion through this period.
What's so interesting when you look at this in hindsight is how it made perfect sense to start the battery revolution with small gadgets. You have lower capital costs to fail at scale, and that's the only place to catch failure. It's not about what you can do in the laboratory or, or what you can do with a couple hundred cells. It's about what you can do when you're making millions and millions and consumers are using them and finding those edge cases that you continue to iterate on in your manufacturing process to make it safer, more reliable, and cheaper cost.
You need the watch, the camcorder, the phone, the laptop to see where it's going to fail, where it's going to get recalled, and what you can learn and learning, as we'll see later, is the essential ingredient here. You can't spin up a battery manufacturing plant and be anywhere close to good in under five years. It's extremely difficult,
not even Goodenough.
And the other thing that this manufacturing revolution does is it brings down the price of lithium orders of magnitude. So a kilowatt-hour of lithium-ion costs about $6,000 in 1995. By 2010, it's $500. That's roughly 90% off the cost in 15 years. And this was coming entirely off of gadgets, mostly laptops, by 2005, lithium-ion had taken rechargeable consumer electronics made in Japan and then increasingly in Korea, running on cobalt oxide, and put them into millions and millions of people's hands and refined a manufacturing process that was ready for a new application.
So at this point, the lithium-ion battery is this amazing piece of technology, especially in all these small gadgets. But if we wanted to scale up the amount of power we're getting from this thing, both in those gadgets and for other use cases, it's still a very expensive battery technology. It really only made sense in these high end consumer electronics. So what we need to do is keep going down that learning curve. And there's two sides of that. One is going to be the manufacturing scale up, which we'll get to. But the other side is that we're not done improving the fundamental battery chemistry.
Let's go back to that anode. Remember, this was the thing that started as a chunk of lithium metal. We moved to that soft carbon out of coke from Yoshino. There was further improvement ahead by going to a hard carbon. We had another 50% energy density, then moving to graphite. This is like pencil lead, high end pencil lead. You get another 25% of energy density. Okay, so that's the journey that the anode's been on. But let's turn to our kind of what feels like the main protagonist of the chemistry story. And that's the cathode.
This is the thing that we had settled on Goodenough's lithium cobalt design,
that layered sponge cake that is able to receive the ions and put them into that layered package.
That's right. And the problem is the Material to make that sponge is very expensive. Cobalt is a very rare material, essentially exclusively mined under some of the harshest conditions in Congo. So it sure be great if there was another, cheaper option to make that sponge out of. And Michael Thackeray, a South African chemist who had worked in Goodenough's Oxford lab, is now at Argonne National Lab right outside of Chicago. His group develops a cathode that essentially dilutes the amount of cobalt you need. In the cathode, they mix nickel, manganese, and cobalt into what's now called an NMC battery.
What was important about it was that it really cut down on the need of that expensive cobalt. And the first move was a third, a third, a third. And then we've continued to innovate since then and basically drive up the chunk of this, that's nickel, and drive further down manganese and cobalt. Today, we're getting to a point where the cathode is mostly nickel. And this is the battery that if you're driving an EV in America, you're probably driving on a lithium NMC battery.
And while nickel is cheaper than cobalt, it's not like there are piles of nickel laying around everywhere. So what could we use to improve the cathode that is cheap and abundant? That's what Goodenough's lab at UT Austin starts to look into. And they investigate iron. Now, the trouble is that iron on its own runs at too low a voltage. So they try bonding it with other elements, namely phosphate, to improve its voltage. And before Goodenough leaves for vacation, he tells his graduate student that this combination won't work.
The crystal's wrong. But the student makes it anyway. And when Goodenough gets back, he's half right. You see, the structure they have allows the lithium-ion to move in and out of it. It's cheap to make, and it holds on to its oxygen, so it's much harder to set on fire. The catch, which Goodenough had predicted, is that lithium moves through it too slowly, so it can't deliver much power. The fix comes out of Quebec from a team that includes the French chemist Michel Armand. They coat each particle in a thin layer of conductive carbon and make the particles smaller.
And the material Goodenough said wouldn't work becomes LFP lithium iron phosphate, the cathode in most of the world's grid storage and a growing share of today's electric cars. When we talk about batteries getting to scale, it's on the backs of an abundant, affordable, safe, reliable, and now decently conductive LFP cathode.
So we've got this amazing invention. Of course we're going to patent it and protect our IP rights. Well, it turns out that we then have this lineup of IP battles coming out of this. You have someone visiting the lab from NTT in Japan who goes back and tries to patent in Japan ahead of the lab. Then you have a battle with yet ming Chang from MIT, who's founding A123 Systems on a very similar chemistry. With all of this, the European patent office decides to revoke the patent in Europe, saying there's not enough novelty here.
And then in China, there's a push from a lot of the new manufacturers to ignore this patent as well. A deal is struck in that case to say as long as you're only manufacturing the batteries for the Chinese market, then we're not going to enforce a patent. As soon as you're trying to go globally, we're going to want to protect it. And so that holds until the patents begin expiring in 2022.
The one thing you can conclude, as Michel Armand said, is the number one property of a lithium iron phosphate battery is that it's an excellent catalyst for human greed. Now, while LFP is being worked on in the lab throughout the 90s and 2000s, the battery that's selling by the millions is still Sony's 18650 cell with a cobalt cathode. And since customers look closely at battery life before buying their new laptop, manufacturers keep packing more and more energy into the same structure with thinner separators and less space between the metals.
Between 1995 and 2010, the energy of a standard cylindrical cell nearly tripled. And every one of those gains was shortening the distance between those two incredibly reactive halves of the cell, the anode and the cathode. And as you shrink that distance, so too do you shrink the safety margin. Now, Fast forward to July 2006. We're in rural Nevada. A couple guys leave their Dell laptop in their Ford pickup truck after a fishing trip. The Dell laptop ignites. The ammunition that's in the glove box catches fire and the fuel tank goes up in flames.
The truck is entirely destroyed. Now, fortunately, those two guys were unhurt. But Dell recalls 4 million battery packs, the largest computer related recall in history. A few days later, Apple has to recall nearly 2 million. Every one of these packs are Sony's. Sony begins replacing nearly all 10 million notebook packs it has made, costing them almost half a billion dollars before any lawsuits hit. And what went wrong? Well, it was fairly Difficult to find out. But Sony's investigation found that the short circuits were due to very microscopic metal particles, believed to be nickel, that was getting inside the cells at an incredibly specific point in the production.
It was so hard to find because the particle only causes fire if it lands in a tiny triangular gap right at the end of the cathode. If that microscopic nickel particle lands anywhere else, it does nothing. So this is why the failure rate is so tiny, why manufacturing is so difficult. It survived every quality test because you needed millions and millions and millions of these products to be out in the market, to have that microscopic particle hit in the exact wrong place to ignite a truck.
It's one thing when it's in a laptop. It's a whole nother issue when it's in a battery up in the sky. So Boeing has just released its 787. This is new flagship planes that everyone's excited about. And these, of course, have more electrical systems that are betting on the newest and greatest lithium-ion batteries. Well, in January 2013, two different incidents happened. One while a 787 was parked in Boston, and another in a flight over Japan, where the same thermal runaway happens again. Fortunately, no one got hurt, but the FAA grounded every 787 in the world.
This is the first time they grounded an entire aircraft type since the 70s. And of course, those batteries were that same lithium cobalt chemistry. Once a fire starts in one of those, it keeps propelling itself. Investigators tried to figure out what happened, and they couldn't actually figure out why these ignited. So they came up with a solution. Put a steel box around each battery
so
that if it ignites, it's going to be isolated. Interestingly enough, this containment strategy is going to echo forward to some other companies in just a moment. These were all ultimately integration failures of a chemistry and a design that is not the most forgiving. So it all comes down to that precision micron level manufacturing that you need to do not just once, like a special surgery, but at a scale of billions and billions of cells over time.
And these fires are genuinely rare. This isn't happening very often relative to the millions of products that are out there. But it's spooky when you have that image going around and everybody's seeing the fires and the recalls.
I think there's like a helplessness to it also. It's not like these devices are necessarily even being misused. It's a tough ball of wax. Well, Sony decides it's not up for the ball of wax, so they decide to Exit the business and they sell off. In 2017, they sell off their entire battery business.
Oh, Sony, don't do it.
Give up
now. Before we get into the next big market of batteries, which may or may not be in your garage, let's take a moment to celebrate where we've come from. First, we found somewhere for the lithium to live, which makes it rechargeable. Thank you, Stan Whittingham and your layered crystal sponge like cathode. Second, we've made it stable and increased the voltage. Thank you, Thackeray and Goodenough for that mixture of new elements into the cathode. Third, we got that metal out because the metal is what's driving so much of the fires.
Thank you, Yoshino, for not ignoring the anode. And fourth, we've taken all those discoveries, built factories and reproduced this millions of times over. Thank you, Sony and Japan, for leading the manufacturing revolution of all of our consumer electronics through the 90s and then going on to teach Korea how to do this. And as we will see shortly, continuing to spread the manufacturing understanding to another very large neighbor in their region. And so all of this culminated in 2019 with a very well deserving Nobel Prize in Chemistry jointly awarded to John Goodenough, Stan Whittingham and Akira Yoshino for the development of lithium-ion batteries, saying that they had laid the foundation for a wireless, fossil fuel free Society.
Goodenough was 97 years old, the oldest laureate ever to have received the Nobel Prize.
Well deserved. There's a quote in a book about the history of the lithium-ion battery in the electric car from Charles Murray. The book is called the Long Hard Road. And I thought this was a good way to reflect on all these developments. He said there hadn't been a linear progression from fundamental research to applied research to engineering. Ford had given birth to the idea of fast ion transport and what could best be described as applied research. Then the idea had zigzagged back and forth between fundamental and applied research, from Ford to Stanford to Exxon to Oxford to France and everywhere else before finally reaching Japan.
Thus, it wasn't a case of R and D. It was R and D and R and D and R and D and R and D. There was nothing linear about it.
And all that knowledge moved by hand, through papers and conference visits and people changing jobs. But today, the industry has a place built for that sharing of knowledge. So we would like to take a moment to thank the Volta Foundation for supporting this episode. In 2019, the same year that Goodenough, Whittingham And Yoshino won the Nobel Prize. Ten battery professionals got together in San Francisco and started the Volta Foundation.
This independent nonprofit has grown into the largest battery association in the world with more than 100,000 battery professionals and over 250 member companies. Volta works across the battery value chain at a global scale and convenes technical committees, publishes cutting edge research and hosts major events for the entire battery industry. In fact, we leaned on some of this research for the creation of this episode, especially their amazing annual battery report. It covers the whole chain from minerals and materials policy impact, cell manufacturing and deployment in grid storage and EVs.
The next battery report comes out in January 2027 and and is available for free at Volta Foundation.
In fact, I think that report might even have a fun little Stepchange cameo in it. Look out for that.
Thank you Volta Foundation for your service to this critical industry and for your partnership.
The EV Revival1988–2012
All right, well, this concludes our chapter on the amazing invention of the lithium-ion battery. It's time for our next story. The comeback of the electric vehicle.
At the start of the last century, when batteries first caught on, cars were one of the first uses. Now there's momentum again, but for very different reasons. Let's put ourselves back in the late 1980s down here in Southern California. Here in LA, there's been 200 days of unhealthy air in a single year. The pollution was out of control. Now the California Air Resources Board CARB had been seeing this problem coming and, and wanted to take every cost effective and technically feasible step available to reduce vehicle emissions.
The chief of this Air Resources Board was convinced that in order to have zero emission cars, we'd have to will this into existence through some top down legislation. So around this time, General Motors Sunracer wins the 1987 World Solar Challenge in Australia. This car goes 42 miles an hour and, and GM gets all excited. It sends its engineers straight to go and build the GM impact concept car which they release on Earth Day 1990. And right around this time, CARB finalizes their Zero Emission Vehicle mandate for the entire industry.
So it's telling all big automakers, you've got to have 2% of your sales emissions free by 1998 and 10% of your sales by 2003. So essentially you've got about a decade to make these products a reality.
So GM goes to work. It's got to figure out how to take this concept car, this one demo unit, and turn it into a production line that's going to supply 2 to 10% of California's vehicle. Needs. It begins this top secret project in California. And they designed this very futuristic car. It almost looks like a teardrop. And they decide when they announce this thing, it's going to be called the EV1. The first EV
original.
It was quite a car to drive. Supposedly it had the initial pep of an EV, right? You step on the pedal and you get immediate torque. It was sleek, it was futuristic. It was actually a two door, two seater coupe. And it was built off some of the most state of the art lead–acid batteries available. Those batteries make up a third of the weight of the car. 26 modules in the pack and a 16 kilowatt-hour pack for the mid-90s. This is a really impressive battery system. And of course there's always the big question of range, right?
Is this going to power people's needs, especially in Southern California? I think you drive a lot down there, don't you? And I,
unfortunately.
And so we spoke to Bob Galyen, who was put on this project after being one of the lead, lead–acid developers at gm, and he was assigned to move out to California to the secret project. And he remembers in the early prototype, colleagues would say that there's no way that a lead–acid battery is going to get this car more than 100 miles. And Bob turns to them and says, I designed this battery. I know how much energy is down there. To the nearest electron, we're going to be able to go for six hours.
So it's him and a data logger in this car. He turns to his data guy and goes, you better go take a piss right now because I'm not stopping to go to the bathroom.
So he drives over six hours for six hours and three minutes at 30 miles an hour to max out the range. And they don't go a hundred miles, they don't go 110 miles. They go 183 miles on that test drive. And supposedly he has a tow truck in advance tracking them to meet them to tow the car back. Because he says, I'm going to drive this thing till the very last bit of charge is used up. The EV1 launches in December of 1996. It's only available as a lease. There's no option to buy this car out. It comes out using that lead–acid pack for a marketed range of 100 miles.
They end up upgrading to a nickel-metal hydride pack that gets up to 150 miles. And the people who lease this thing supposedly love it. They adore it. It's the first time they've had a taste of EVs it's, it works great. And LA is the perfect launch market because people are often driving, they're able to charge up at night and they get that first taste of the EV experience. It's like a flashback to the city dwellers of 1910 and a flash forward to the future that we all live in now.
This comes about the turn of the century, right? And so not everybody's excited. There's a bit of a vibe shift happening at the same time, whether it's amongst the automakers, the oil industry or the new Bush administration. To be fair, the mandate is fairly aggressive. The car companies aren't with it. They're dragging their feet. They're eventually going to sue. Gas is really cheap. 911 happens and reinvigorates good old American patriotism. And the Hummer's about to come out. The industry and government decide on a new focal area, perhaps a distraction.
They choose hydrogen and call it the Freedom Car. Bush puts about $1 billion behind a fuel cell program on a 10 to 15 year horizon. Meaning nobody's got to do anything anytime soon. But we can redirect all of our energy to this idea that we're going to have hydrogen powered cars. The NRDC actually says the Freedom Car is really about Bush's freedom to do absolutely nothing about cars today.
You're supposed to go to McDonald's in your freedom Car to get your freedom fries. What an era that was.
The vibes take over, right? You've got a fuel cell maker in Vancouver that has no profits, but for a moment in time is worth more than a traditional automaker. And oil companies are salivating at a new product line that they can own, or at least a way to delay this EV hype.
Yeah, and we're here talking about the EV1, but Toyota had released an EV RAV4. There's kind of like these various models to try. In total, during this era, carmaker shipped about 4,000 battery electric vehicles under the CARB mandate. The goal, mind you, was tens of thousands. So it just becomes clear this isn't happening. CARB ends up pushing the various mandates out. The car makers come together and sue to stop it and they rewrite the mandate to remove all of its teeth and obviously align towards this proposed shift to hydrogen.
The nuance to add here is that the cost of batteries had not collapsed in this decade the way that it would have needed to to make the economic case. In 1990, when CARB was first putting the mandate into place, they said the battery is going to add maybe 1300 to the price of a car, not a significant factor. By 94 they said maybe 5 to 10,000. But by 2000 they said the incremental additional cost of an EV would was going to be $20,000, which is an entirely different economic proposition. And so with all of this, GM, the kind of hero that made the EV1 happen in the impact, turns and decides to do to many of the leases the unthinkable.
They collect these cars that they love out of the lease, bring them to the proving grounds in Arizona and crush them. To be fair, this is like a pilot car. It was not yet scaled up for mass production,
but it was against the consumer's desire. Right. These consumers were not willing to give back their cars.
That's right, many of them. They banded together for the last 78 cars and wrote this kind of large $2 million check to say, hey, could we buy these EV ones from you? We want to keep them. Sure enough, no. GM took them and crushed them. And a documentary was made of this called who Killed the Electric Car? That is a dramatic but powerful retelling of this moment in EV history. Inside gm, the main conclusion was fairly simple. It was, yes, we made those cars. That's quite different than making an economical, profitable product that we can sell.
Those were not on a production line that we were ready to scale up. In retrospect, GM CEO at the time, Rick Wagoner looks back and said that killing the EV1 was his worst decision. It didn't affect profitability, but it did affect our Image. So by 2003, every company that had built an electric car under this CARB mandate had stopped.
Across the ocean, Japan is taking a much more pragmatic approach to this whole question of how do we improve fuel efficiency, how do we get a better car on the road? And introduces a hybrid. So Toyota started a project in the mid-90s to design a small car with a large cabin and at least one and a half times the fuel economy of a comparable car. The Prius goes on sale in December 1997, one day before the Kyoto Climate Treaty is adopted in the same city. Now, this Prius can go 52 miles a gallon more than double a Camry, and becomes the first mass produced car since the 1920s to offer an alternative to that traditional internal combustion engine.
And so under the rear seat sits a 1.8 kilowatt-hour nickel-metal hydride battery, which is roughly 3% of the size of the battery in a modern EV pack. Now, Toyota chose nickel-metal hydride because it was the safest, most durable battery to put inside a car at the right price. And to do this, Toyota set up a captive battery company with Panasonic, who had been making nickel-metal hydride batteries at scale for a number of years. And the Prius took off, as we know, at the 2003 Oscars you had Cameron Diaz, Harrison Ford and Susan Sarandon all arriving in Priuses, making it a status symbol across California and the country.
So it's in this era that a couple of very non automotive guys start poking around. They look at all of this historical failure of the auto industry to make an electric vehicle and they start to wonder, has no one ever heard of or looked into the lithium-ion battery? We had the chance to speak with Martin Eberhard who was about to found Tesla and was looking at this market and he said everybody who ought to be our competitors have very publicly and very expensively gotten themselves out of the market, famously just suing CARB and ending this mandate.
Tesla was not founded by car people who went looking to find a battery. Martin and Marc Tarpenning are engineers who have worked together since the late 80s in Silicon Valley. They had built one of the earliest ebook readers and sold it in 2000 at the height of the dot com boom for almost $200 million. And inside of that ebook reader they had worked with different battery cells and different chemistries. They'd use lithium-ion batteries and shipped them in a real product. So these were naturally already top of mind.
Martin goes looking at this point he just wants a fast battery powered car. And so he goes around meeting people and he finds this company, AC Propulsion out of San Dimas. They're actually founded in 92 by the same engineers who had built that GM impact car that was the early prototype of the EV1. This AC Propulsion company essentially existed to make demonstration vehicles for car makers at auto shows. And now that whole electric business is drying up. So Martin meets with them and they have this electric sports car concept called a T0 and they're building this on lead–acid.
So he persuades AC Propulsion to build a T0 on lithium-ion cells and pays for it as a first customer. Now mind you, they have no interest in becoming a production car company. Meanwhile, Martin's spending time with his old co founder Mark and he's trying to convince him that this is a good idea. He builds this whole spreadsheet model, a well to wheel model of every energy pathway you can think of to move a car. This is crude and diesel to gasoline, hybrids, hydrogen, EVs. He realized that even if the electricity is generated with coal.
The worst you could do with an electric car was the same as the best you could do with the most efficient gasoline car. And this spreadsheet actually was turned into a white paper that we'll link to in the show notes. It's a pretty amazing artifact, the founding thesis of Tesla. Well, around the same time, Martin is having a coffee with Mark and says, I came up with the name of the company. We're going to call it Tesla Motors. Mark opens up his laptop and says, I got it. I got the domain name tesla motors.com and they incorporate the company.
July 2003, Martin goes back to AC Propulsion, gets his T0 that's now built out, can go 0 to 60 in 3.6 seconds, has nearly 7,000 laptop cells. Again, it's a concept car, but he's now able to use this to go on a fundraising journey down Sandhill.
They were already leaned in to lithium-ion batteries and had built it into this concept car. The question for them wasn't about chemistry, it was entirely about trust. And the consumer electronics industry had created the trust and conditions to allow them to experiment with lithium-ion. They also had a product philosophy that they were operating with in the early days of Tesla, which is that new technologies enter as luxuries. You got laptops, flat screens, air conditioners. They all enter in the premium market and then move down.
And so if you apply that same philosophy to a new EV, it means that Tesla no longer has to look at only the cheapest options available.
And this is a complete 180, if you like. Think about the other car manufacturers. Whenever they look at introducing the EV or the hybrid, they're trying to make this. Like Toyota Camry competitor Tesla flips the script by going up market.
That's right. And we'll see this. GM continues to stay on that older mentality. So what is Tesla using? They choose these cylindrical 18650 lithium-ion cells. We've been talking about laptop battery cells. They're expensive, but they perform well. And they're the only cell that can be made at volume. And according to Martin, that's the entire reason that Teslas are built on these batteries. Now, at the same time, there's a young Stanford engineering grad, JB Straubel, who famously converted an old Porsche into an electric car.
In 2003, he meets Elon over lunch, and Elon gives him $10,000 to build a lithium-ion EV. JB introduces Elon to AC Propulsion. They aren't interested in selling cars, so they point him to Martin and Mark, and Elon ends up leading Tesla's Series A because, you know, that's how these things happen. And with JB as the cto, the other design principle that Tesla anchored on early is one that we still hear about today. Range anxiety. In those early days, Tesla asked people, when do you start looking for a gas station? And the answer that came back was about a quarter tank, which is 50 to 60 miles left.
They wanted range at parity with gas cars at about 250 miles. And with lithium-ion, that means a very large, very expensive pack. So if you're going to have a large, expensive pack and go upmarket, it's going to be a sports car. There's also a hidden benefit to a big pack built from small cells. If any one cell goes into thermal runaway, it's a tiny fraction of the pack's energy, and the pack can still survive it. Build a pack from a few dozen big cells and one failure takes down the whole product. So they end up with 6831 laptop cells and a bet that lithium-ion keeps getting cheaper.
So a car that looks marginally viable in the early 2000s will look obvious by the time the incumbents are ready to take action.
And so there's this dual thing of having so many individual cells in a large package. The industry would say you're only gonna have a bad cell one in 10 million, like, okay, that's pretty good. In a nine cell laptop, it's gonna feel like it's never gonna fail. But you put 7000 cells in a car, and that means that one car in 1500 is gonna have a bad cell that's gonna go in thermal runaway. Many other manufacturers had no interest in taking that type of risk. Tesla looked at that and realized they just had to design around it.
At some point. They don't trust some of the cell manufacturer spec sheets. So they take a hot nail, stick it through the bottom of one of these 18, 6, 50 cells, and it explodes and shoots itself up on top of their office roof from the parking lot. And so they look at this whole thermal runaway problem, and it starts actually slipping and delaying their target dates for the Roadster. And they realize that this is the key thing they need to get a handle on. So Martin actually digs a hole in the front yard of his house, puts a camera down there along with a pack of cells, puts some plywood and a cinder block on so it doesn't, you know, explode over to his house and sets off the cells in thermal Runaway.
The camera actually melts down and explodes, but the SD card inside survives. So they look at this footage and they realize this key insight. There are three ways that the heat is going to leave a cell that's in runaway. Either the hot guts get essentially ejected out of the top of the cell. It could be that heat radiates to the neighbors without it necessarily exploding. And then actual conduction through the mounting and cooling that you might have connected to the cell inside the pack. And so with this realization, and with this fundamental engineering assumption that you're going to have cells in your cars that will occasionally hit runaway, they figured that the only real viable answer was to design for it.
Space the cells, just right, route it so that if something ejects out of a cell, it escapes without heating and hitting the next cell over. Let's make it actually possible to design for failure. There's a lot of amazing things that Tesla got right, but I actually think this fundamental engineering decision around the lithium-ion cells is what actually propels them for years ahead of the rest of the industry. And they have to invent everything else in the car also. Right. There's no existing battery management system that's been designed for this application, so they have to design their own battery management chips.
They have to figure out when they're wire bonding the cells. The perfect thickness of the wire bond that's strong enough to hold up in a car, but just thin enough that if it burns out, it fuses to the cell. And all of this is being done by hand. They're literally shipping over the chassis from the UK and finishing production in the back of their dealership to get the first cars made.
That's right. And at the same time, as we talked about, the Dell recall happens, kicking off all of these fears just a month after the Roadster is revealed to the public.
Now, it's one thing to design it, it's another thing to convince suppliers to send you tens of thousands of cells. And the key question that Tesla kept running into is, who's going to be blamed when this fails? And so Tesla goes out and engages all the big lithium battery makers in Asia. Most of them are not interested at first. LG refuses. Then they turn around, ship them a pallet of cells, find out it's going to be used for a car, and make Tesla ship it back. Because they don't want to be involved. Panasonic initially says no, but they somehow continue to engage.
Sanyo's factory boss says, I don't want to get into the automotive business. That has no margin. Tesla's argument is, listen, you guys are maybe going to sell 10, 20, 30 batteries across the lifetime of a customer. I'm giving you the opportunity to sell 7,000 to that customer. Find me a market that is as good as that for you. And this was a fairly compelling argument. So Sanyo and Panasonic end up more deeply engaging, sending out sample cells. And Tesla does their own quality research and actually sends back the data.
Charge them hard, drain them hard, push them into thermal Runway, blow them up. They document all of this and send all the results back to the cell makers. Now, instead of filing away that data like some do, Panasonic actually engages. They find it interesting because they've been making these batteries for so long that they're really interested in what this data holds and actually iterating with Tesla. One observation is how the little can is busting and Panasonic is like, oh, what if we put a vent in there? And Tesla's like, yeah, try that and like perforate the top of the cap and send it back and forth.
And what's amazing about this is you've got this tiny startup operating on a dream in the back of their San Carlos office, engaging with this huge old entrenched Japanese company. And credit to Panasonic for actually taking them seriously, actually seeing the vision the team had, seeing the market there, and genuinely engaging to iterate on these batteries to make it viable. So we can get to the summer of 2006 and finally unveil Tesla's first car, the Roadster. It sells out in three weeks. And starting in 2008, it's shipping the car for about $100,000.
That can go 244 miles, ultimately producing nearly 2,500 of these cars. And as we mentioned, everything's being done by hand. These lithium-ion batteries being stitched together, which ends up making the cost of this car way higher than what they were able to charge, apparently almost 50% more. Now it was never supposed to be manufacturing scale. The whole point was to prove a concept. But in proving this concept and selling 2,500 Roadsters, Tesla's also losing over $100 million in the first few years of production.
It gets so bad that as Christmas of 2008 approaches amidst the global financial crisis, Tesla's hours away from missing payroll before closing a $40 million financing round. They're pulling off all this incredible design innovation, getting by with the skin of their teeth to prove that this market is viable. And, and this product, a lithium-ion powered electric car, can be competitive with any gas powered car on the market.
And so let's go back to Detroit where those gas powered cars and that industry has sitting there saying an EV is not a good idea. We're all in on hydrogen. Right. And so GM is in a bit of a, a low point. At the end of 2006, GM had lost nearly 10 billion. The year before, they'd killed the EV1 and were in a reputational spiral. And a startup with a couple hundred employees had announced a car that did the thing that GM said didn't make sense. And so leadership is pissed off. Bob Lutz says at a meeting, how is it that everybody at GM convinces me that this can't be done and no one is going to tell me anymore that it's not feasible.
And so at the 2007 auto show, GM announces not yet a car, but a new architecture. The idea was really the structure of a plug in hybrid. Have enough battery on board for most people for their daily commute, 40, 50 miles and then have an internal combustion engine that can kick on when needed for a longer drive. The first car that they're going to announce on this platform is the Chevy Volt. And so to find the battery they're going to use for their first car here, they run two suppliers against each other. LG Chem has a Michigan subsidiary based on a manganese oxide chemistry against A123's lithium iron phosphate.
But then of the year they've chosen the safe, larger company bet, which is LG's product based on the chemistry that came out of Argonne's National Lab and our friend Michael Thackeray. And they also went with this old school thinking in the automotive industry which is to push liability onto your supplier. And so they said that LG is going to deliver these perfect cells. These are going to be quote unquote automotive grade cells. Well, we talked to people in the battery industry and they said there's no such thing as automotive grade cells.
There's just probabilities that something's going to go wrong. But one more note on A123, I mean this was a formative startup of the time. A123 was spun out of Yet-Ming Chiang's materials lab at MIT and started selling an early LFP battery, first to the power tools market and then to Fisker Automotive. They had the largest IPO of 2009. But as we've learned again and again, it's not just about battery chemistry and what you discover in the lab. It's about manufacturing and the precision of your manufacturing. And so in 2012, a miscalibrated welding machine in their factory led to the recall of all of Fisker Automotive's battery packs, costing them over $50 million and drained the company of cash.
Fisker goes bankrupt and A123 ends up selling to a Chinese company for a fraction of its IPO raise. So that LFP design that A123 had fought so hard to get out in the market from a US based company has now been further acquired into China.
Now, it's not coincidental that you mention our LFP technology going to China, because we're going to go to China next to remind us what's happening in the macro environment. All of this is happening against the backdrop of the global financial crisis. Oil goes through the roof, our car makers are going through bankruptcy, Obama announces the Recovery Act. And as part of that, there is this vision around battery manufacturing. In the US we have nearly two and a half billion dollars of grants going towards battery projects with a goal of making 40% of the world's advanced batteries in this country by 2015.
Alongside a number of loans for EV companies and EV car batteries. Coming out of half a decade of trying to build this hydrogen freedom car, the US is backing the supply side for EVs and the thought here is that if we can make batteries, then we can sell the cars. Problem was that the sales didn't really follow. And then you've got Solyndra and Fisker and A123, all these startups that are getting government backing flaming out and hitting a really tough political environment. One bright side is Tesla actually gets one of these loans, buys up a shuttered Toyota plant in Fremont and pays back the loans nine years early.
And so while America did initially step up as a lender and it paid for some factories, as soon as some of these bankruptcies hit and customers weren't flocking to the EVs, the industry lost its nerve. And I think the big lesson we take away from this is building an EV market requires high performing, affordable batteries manufactured consistently at scale. And you can't do this without a policy environment and clear market signals and a stable investment ecosystem to weather the years and years of inevitable fires and inevitable bad welding machines.
These mistakes are going to happen. You need the enabling environment to push through if you have a long term vision of transforming your automotive industry. And so all of those technologies that we've developed in the US have now been shipped over across the seas. And that combines with their manufacturing Prowess to create the next decade of just an absolute revolution in battery manufacturing and production that happens almost exclusively in Asia. So that's our chapter on the electric cars comeback. From California's mandate and GM's EV1 to Tesla's first Roadster.
How China Won the Battery2009–2025
Now it's time to travel east to see what it actually takes to make batteries at scale. And our next chapter on who ends up dominating the supply chain.
So a battery war is about to unfold. But this hasn't been appreciated by the larger industry yet. One man sees some parallels. It's 2009 and Andy Grove, the famed former chairman of Intel. He lived through the challenge when Japan in the 80s took over the chip and memory business and had to pivot Intel to microprocessors. Well, he's worried that the same thing is about to happen in energy. So he calls in the team from Argonne National Labs and says the stakes are even higher because a country that cannot meet its own energy needs will be at the political and economic mercy of those who could.
And abandoning today's commodity manufacturing can lock you out of tomorrow's emerging industry. And perhaps most presciently, as the team is leaving his house, he says winning a manufacturing game is nine rounds. It's a boxing match. You will lose the first round. You'll probably lose the first two or three rounds. But always remember, the game is nine rounds.
Grove nailed it. No place. Do you see this nine round metaphor be truer than on the battery manufacturing floor? Let's take a quick trip to that floor. And lithium-ion battery has an electrode that's about 100 microns thick. That's about the thickness of a sheet of paper and a separator between two halves that's thinner than a human hair. And then they're operating with powder, and the enemy is a speck of metal because a stray particle is what shorts a cell, as we saw earlier. Then you coat that foil, and at this time, you can move about as fast as you can walk to the thickness of something you can't see, producing no gap, no ridge, no break.
As one engineer told us who was examining all the faults, you can't screw up a coating line. You'll spend an entire day clearing out a foil break. And we're talking about foil wound to the tolerance of microns in a room drier than any desert on Earth. And then you have to charge it for the first time very slowly on a specific recipe to grow the skin on the anode. Set it out for a few days and then see does it hold its charge? This is clearly a few boxing rounds before you can get it right. And the knowledge of this lives in people.
You can write down as many manuals as you can produce, but it really lives in those that have been on that floor. And it moves when they move. So as we mentioned, Japan owned the 90s, having the consumer electronics industry and Sony starting to manufacture cells. But the culture in Japan was to forcibly retire engineers in their mid-50s. And so you had all this expertise and knowledge looking for something to do, getting hired away into Korea as consultants. And you see it on the floor as you walk into a Sanyo or Sony factory and you're walking on a green anti static floor.
Then you go over to Korean factories and you're walking on the same green floor. China plays out in roughly the same way, the same defects in the same order, country by country. And so this is the knowledge that transfers around Asia. Now we bring up China. Why is China also bringing in these green anti static floors? Well, it's because of the mobile phone. You had about 2 million mobile subscribers in 1995 and 200 million just seven years later. By 2024, China would be making about 80% of the world's battery cells.
In addition to those hundreds of millions of mobile phone subscribers, you have a state policy that has been brewing for decades and kicks into gear at the turn of the century.
Yeah, so we go back to the mid-80s in March 1986 and four famed Chinese scientists, four physicists from the nuclear and satellite programs write a letter to Deng Xiaoping proposing to end China's reliance on foreign technology. And he endorses it within two days. This program is known as the 863 program for March 86 and it takes nearly 5% of government annual spending and puts it towards research and development. Now this includes some questionable practices to acquire foreign technology, but it puts in this notion of the country's own self reliance on technology.
And it slots into China's pre existing planning cycle known as the famous five year plans. Well in 2001 that program kicks off a New Energy Vehicle Roadmap. It has taken five cycles of that five year plan and now 25 years later, it's taken China's EV manufacturing to where it is today. So what was in that 2001 plan? Well the first interesting thing is that they captain engineer who had spent a decade at Audi and brought him home to run their vehicle program. He'd later become the Minister of Science and Technology.
In the key years from 2007 to 2018 and so he wrote this plan. The framework was three different verticals, three horizontals. We're going to be open to hybrid battery, electric, fuel cell, and we're going to make sure we control the horizontals, the powertrain, control the motors and the batteries. We're going to see which one plays out and which one wins, and then we're going to put all of our state weight behind that. This starts to create quite a set of innovations and markets around batteries. And I think it's time that we talk about perhaps the most important battery company in the world today.
A company that I think many people have maybe even never heard the name of, even if they use their products.
Contemporary Amperex Technology Limited, Otherwise known as CATL. CATL is the largest battery maker on earth, and it didn't exist until just 15 years ago. If you're driving an EV today, it's very likely that CATL makes its cells. Ben, your wife just left to go pick up your kids in your Volvo.
I looked up last week and I was like, oh, those are CATL batteries. I didn't know.
There you go. Their sibling company, ATL, makes the batteries in your phone. CATL has an absolutely fascinating history. We're going to try and keep that related to the history of batteries. But it truly is an extraordinary company that was born from Robin Zeng's vision. Robin Zeng is born during the Cultural Revolution in a mountain village. He's a super good student, gets a really safe state job after graduation, which he ends up quitting months later to join a subsidiary of TDK, which is a Japanese company that happens to be the world's largest maker of hard drive heads.
So Robin works his way up over the years until 1999 when he and and two other senior execs leave to form a battery company called ATL, with Robin as the product man. Now, the story of ATL is so fascinating and contains a number of these big gambles that Robin and those execs make that really form the future of the battery industry. The first of those gambles was raising $2 million and then promptly spending half of it on a Bell Labs lithium polymer license. Now, this license had been used by at least 20 other companies, and they supposedly all failed because the product would ultimately swell up.
Well, ATL's team of engineers solves the swelling within a couple weeks. Now, they're not doing this to beat some competitor to fill a known gadget need or go after some mundane market. No, this is a bet. The company move with their last remaining bit of Cash. They need to develop a flat pouch to fit into a flat product that simply cannot hold the cylindrical cells available, which is why they needed this license from Bell Labs to be able to do it. So we're in the early 2000s flat product, big risk, big reward.
The Sony Walkman was important. The disposable batteries we just talked about, it just turns out people like to walk around with music, right? And you know what? A tape doesn't have enough music. Let's put a hard drive in that baby. Let's give you a wheel on it, and let's release the Apple iPod. The iPod comes out in 2001, and by 2003, production is ramping, and Apple's looking for the best supplier possible. And it turns to this startup essentially in China, ATL, and they sign this landmark deal. So that deal sets ATL's habit for years to come.
Win the most demanding customer first, the one that pays for quality, and then scale up
as on the backs of this TDK as its earlier investor ends up buying a majority stake in ATL. And then Robin starts to explore another big market, the budding car market and EVs. And so after a few years, he comes across a government initiative that wants to show off some EV buses at a fairly large event in 2008 in Beijing.
The Olympics.
The Beijing Olympics. ATL wins a bid to build batteries for a demo fleet of electric buses during the Beijing Olympics. Similar to the Big Leap with Apple, ATL is once again operating on the world stage. But this time, the Chinese government is its customer and overseer. So it has to take this seriously and deliver. And this marks the company's first foray into into the EV market. Now, right around this time, China is about to overtake the US as the world's largest car market. And the Chinese government is under intense pressure from citizens and the global media to do something about its incredibly polluted skies.
So it launches what's called the Ten Cities Thousand Vehicles program, a goal of deploying a thousand EVs into ten of its largest cities. Well, this actually catches hold and the number grows to north of 25 cities. This sends a signal across the country, leading to a proliferation of startups, of car manufacturing companies, and all the parts suppliers that go around this. And so Robin's getting excited. He pitches ATL to go after this market, but TDK is just not quite seeing it yet. And so they let a small subsidiary with an ATL go after this.
But lo and behold, ATL's history is written for them because Beijing comes out with a new rule that breaks the TDK arrangement in 2011. The new energy vehicle subsidies are now going to be tied to domestic technology ownership. That means the battery supplier has to be a majority Chinese owned in order to supply the Chinese EV market.
They would like their car companies to get high on their own supply.
So now the car battery arm has to be spun out 85% Chinese owned. And instead of being called ATL, they slap a C onto it and called CATL. Not for China, but for
contemporary.
Contemporary. CATL moves across the street from ATL and it's hilarious because they share the same cafeteria, they share the same daycare, they have the same badges. CATL's renting lines from ATL. The engineers are married to each other across the company. And so this is a little bit more separation in form rather than in reality. But CATL gets up and running in 2012.
And so Robin and the ATL crew that are moving over to CATL obviously know how to make batteries, but they've never run production lines at automotive scale. And they need someone that automotive buyers are going to trust. And so they call up our friend from earlier in the episode, Bob Galyen. Remember that EV1? Well, he's the battery pack designer that drove it for over six hours straight. Well, he's back. And at this point, he's spent nearly 25 years in lead–acid plants working with GM and the European carmakers, so he has their trust.
Robin sees him at a conference and invites him over to dinner. Bob walks into dinner and there are 56 CATL engineering managers sitting there waiting to hear from him. Supposedly, he has a shot of Maotai, with most of them impressing them greatly. He joins as CATL's first CTO and together they decided to focus on prismatic cells instead of the cylindrical ones. Prismatic cells are these hard rectangular boxes and they'd be a perfect fit for the LFP chemistry that they're about to scale up. But first, they need a customer.
ATL had Apple with the iPod release. What's the car company that will push them to build the best possible cell? Bob immediately knows the answer and says to Robin, we got to go for BMW. And it's perfect timing. BMW has a joint venture in China called Brilliance, and they want to build an electric car. And true to form, they hold their suppliers to extremely high standards. So BMW engages and hands CATL an 800 page specification for the battery. CATL meets it. Bob spends nine months training 2000 engineers to run the new production lines.
And they're off to the races. They're focused now on high end cells for BMW and the like. But it just so happens that all of a sudden they gotta pivot some of their focus back to buses. Why buses? Well, because cities were being heavily polluted by buses. The level of pollution in Beijing was 25 times what the World Health Organization recommended. There's a recycling tycoon who's kind of as a lark selling 8 million cans of fresh air over 10 days to raise awareness of this problem. So it's not just an inconvenience or a discomfort.
This smog is killing lots of people. And so the society, the government says it's time to do something about this. If we have this battery manufacturing capability, let's go electrify buses. And so what type of battery would you use in a bus? Two things I think became really clear to Robin and Bob and the team. The first is that LFP back to our friend lithium iron phosphate was the right chemistry for this problem. The second is that instead of putting that LFP into cylindrical cells, we can actually make them into boxes that are larger and have a bunch of structural properties that fit better for buses.
The thing that's awesome about buses is they run on a fixed schedule, so you know how far it needs to go and when it needs to charge. And you take a chemistry like LFP that's not as efficient as the other chemistries, it doesn't matter. You've got this entire bus architecture. You can slap on a bunch of these modules and run it for exactly as long as you need. Not having to worry about efficiency, but getting all the gains of cost, safety and durability
to that point. LFP is highly durable, it can handle a lot of cycles. And if it does ignite, which it's going to happen, it's going to happen at a lower temperature. So there's kind of a built in fact of safety which was shared with us, was a concern of the governments that they recognize that there's going to be potential runaway fires. But on buses they're extra concerned about the number of people that could be impacted.
I mean we are far from being experts on China, but you do realize how much of state policy and state culture is built on stability. That's why they attack the pollution issue. It is destabilizing their cities. When they approach something like buses and they start seeing bus fires, it's again destabilizing. So they are very, very concerned with safety because that drives an orderly society and trust in the government services. And so Bob's going out there and inspecting all of these bus fires himself and recommending exactly how to retool the architecture so you don't put the battery in the back just slapped on where the motor was.
You've got to position it such that it's not going to have the greatest impact and it's going to survive you that crash with a concrete truck.
That's right. And they start investing significantly in safety. Supposedly CATL has its own building where they're able to essentially explode buses and design them and test them and see how the fires are going to break out in this all is transformative. Shenzhen's entire bus fleet was electrified by the end of 2017. But there's still the cars on the road and the government and everyone else wants those to go all electric as well. So China has subsidies in the mid 2010s that cut the average sticker price of an electric vehicle in half.
And of course, they required that car makers buy domestic cells. And while CATL quality was going up, not all domestic cells are treated equal. There is a different approach to some of the problems that we've talked about. If a cell was low quality and self ignites, oftentimes the manufacturer would essentially pay out for the problem and there wouldn't be a mass recall because they're trying to support the cell industry and getting it going. It's a very different approach to the environment we have in the US on this.
Totally. The other huge turning point for CATL comes in 2015 when the government again steps in to make a white list of approved cell providers to meet the condition of the subsidy. 57 domestic makers are certified and CATL is at the top of this list. Most notably Panasonic, Samsung and LG now can't supply this massive growing Chinese domestic market. And so with this exclusionary tactic, by 2017, CATL passes Panasonic to become the largest cell maker in the world, just five years after its technical formation.
Wow.
Some reports show that between 2009 and 2023, the state put in at least $230 billion of support. Contrast that to our Obama Recovery Act of two and a half billion dollars and you can see the difference it makes when you try and create a complex industry.
And by the end of the decade, you're in 2019, 2020 and the state can essentially let go. They don't need to incentivize the construction of the market. The market is there. And not just that. It's a time now for the market to be in a place to export. So Back to our friend the lithium iron phosphate chemistry, or LFP, because it's worth appreciating some more of the mechanics of integration that LFP affords. Now, remember, LFP was invented in Texas by Goodenough's group in the mid-90s and then went through this ramp up of production.
And it was initially dismissed, especially by American automakers, as not being dense enough for what the consumers wanted. In terms of a high range EV, it's at 160 watt hours, a kilogram cell today against 250 for a high nickel NMC chemistry, that's a third less energy per kilogram of weight. And so Western automakers viewed it as this thing that's only relevant to maybe the Chinese buses and taxi fleets where weight and range weren't as big of a concern. They never thought it could really power an American car. One big engineering design mentality that they were taking to this was really about thinking about it at the cell level and not the system level.
For the conventional NMC pack, you have all of these cells as modules in a pack and each of those extra layers, including the cylindrical can around a cell and adds weight, adds material, adds cost, adds structure. With LFP, you can ship what's called a cell to pack design that removes a lot of the extra space in between. And with this pack design, you have larger cells giving you more surface area to reject heat and actually safer redundancy. All of this makes LFP much more able to compete with NMC and affords you the ability to look at it much more from a system level than a cell level.
And our very impressive friends at CATL aren't the only ones who drove the LFP market. To fully appreciate the dominance of this battery, we've got to talk about the EV Godzilla BYD. Now, the story of BYD or build your dreams is fascinating and full of twists and turns. It started off as a battery company, it bought a car company, then it became a vertically integrated monster and the largest user of LFP batteries in the world. We normally associate it today as a car company, but we were surprised to learn that it's also the manufacturer that assembles 30% of Apple's iPads.
BYD makes monorails, forklifts, solar panels, and even a fleet of car carrying ships. As of this year, BYD employs over a million people around the world. That's more than Toyota, GM, Ford and Tesla combined.
These guys just know how to scale up. So February 2020 hits in one Shenzhen plant, they were making phone batteries. Five weeks later, that Same factory was the world's largest manufacturer of masks, putting out 5 million masks a day.
They just know how to build stuff. And who are they? Well, BYD was started by Wang Chuanfu, who was born in a farming family and raised by his siblings. He's a metallurgist by trade, and in 1995 starts BYD in Shenzhen by buying Japanese batteries, reverse engineering them and reading the Japanese patents to figure out what they are. He doesn't really care about chemistry. He's all about how can I manufacture something and sell it? And so once he knows how to build a commercial cell that works, his focus is on making them cheaper.
And his big innovation is replacing Japanese robots on the battery manufacturing line with human labor in China. And it works. His early sales cost $3 versus $8 in Japan. He starts selling to Motorola and Nokia, and by 2002, BYD is the world's largest nickel–cadmium battery maker. But this doesn't come without a cost, right? Turnover in his factories are really high, and early BYD descriptions read like they're straight out of England's industrial age. I mean, we're talking deplorable labor practices. A few months later, they ipo.
And what's interesting is nothing mentions an expansion into the auto industry. But right after the ipo, Wang goes and buys a majority stake in a failing state owned car maker. BYD's shares fall 20% that day and the market thinks he's crazy. And his play is, I can manufacture cars better. So he's just going to bring BYD's manufacturing discipline to this line
and his timing is somewhat impeccable and he's built this manufacturing powerhouse which at the time is not going after a large private car market. For context, in 2002 it was only about a million a year, but the next year, 2003, that same market has doubled to 2 million cars a year.
And so now that BYD has a car company, it needs a car battery. Its nickel–cadmium batteries aren't built for purpose in a car setting. And a series of patent issues actually prevent BYD from adopting the nickel-metal hydride batteries that we saw earlier being used in the Prius and the EV1. So what does he do? Turns to LFP. Oh, it's got no cobalt. Oh, I don't have a huge supply chain risk. I've got no patent issues. And this one decision helps push the entire market towards LFP. After getting exposure to the bus and fleet market, he returns to passenger cars and actually launches a plug in hybrid two years before the Volt.
This is 2008. This is the same year that Berkshire Hathaway, flush with cash, they're looking across after the great financial crisis, saying, what good investments can we go make? And they swoop in and buy 10% of BYD for $230 million. And a lot of it was an immense admiration for the founder. Charlie Munger says this guy is a combination of Edison and Jack Welch. Something like Edison in solving technical problems and something like what Welch does in terms of getting things done. It's one of only two times, supposedly that Munger pounds the table to make an investment.
BYD and Costco.
By 2020, they're selling close to half a million vehicles. By 2022, they stopped making gas powered cars altogether. And by 2024 they're selling 4 million vehicles a year. That's a tenfold increase in four years. And that scale up puts them past Tesla as the world's largest EV maker.
And so in 2026, they're now targeting something like five and a half million vehicles and exporting nearly half of those. Just for context, GM sells about 6 million vehicles globally. Perhaps there's a bit of an overshoot, right, Because China's domestic market is 27 million cars a year. It's a lot of cars, but its carmakers could produce 55 million and they were able to ramp up and build factories quickly. And so now there's becoming a concern of an oversupply of car making manufacturing capacity in the world and the West.
While our car has cells made at CATL in China, if you look around, there's increasing resistance. You can't go buy a Chinese manufactured EV very easily, right?
That's right. And so you look at what BYD did, their cell was never the best cell. It wasn't a lithium-ion battery that we've seen in Tesla. It's this lithium iron phosphate that's made cheaply enough that is safe, reliable and fit for purpose. BYD wins on cost, replacing robots with people. And 15 years later, it's the largest maker of electric cars in the world. Just absolutely astounding,
wild story. And so if you just look at the last four or five years from where we are today, and you look at the story of China and the EV market, it is a story of scale. We just talked about CATL, BYD, but there's a long list of other companies. This is Geely that went and bought Volvo and Polestar, this is Cherry, Nio Xiaomi. You have this whole wave of Chinese EV manufacturers that are Starting to build out as essentially the new automaker manufacturing hub of the world. In 2023, China surpasses Japan as the world's largest car exporter.
Of Those in the EV market, CATL supplies roughly 40% of EV batteries and BYD another 20%. And even Tesla in different markets is buying cells from CATL and BYD. These are fundamental supply chains of the world. Now
the scale up story is so endemic of the culture and economy in China. We were talking to one engineer in China working in these manufacturing plants and he says that you simply cannot move fast enough. It is so cutthroat. Everywhere you turn, a new competitor springing up. So if you aren't growing month on month, year on year at some insane rate, you're going to get gobbled up, you're going to get cut out of price and buyers are switching suppliers on pennies. Essentially you have an entire industry where not only are you making the battery, you're making all of the other pieces that go into it.
And they're all in the same town, they're across the street. Your vendor negotiations are walking down the street and meeting three different suppliers. Not doing what we do in the US which is like book that once or twice a year trip to China, meet the few folks that we can get introduced to and try and pick the best. No, no. Like there's an entire ecosystem and you know everyone and they're all working to be a part of this incredible growth story.
Yeah, I think the other thing, it's the cutthroat competition, but it's, it's not a race just on cost. Like early on, that's how BYD got in. But now, especially on the sell side, it's been a race to quality. CATL's decision to choose Apple and then BMW as first customers forced an immediate kind of the starting line of the race on quality. And then the rest of the race is scale. And the way you get economic scale for cells is by having a high yield, meaning the cells that come out of your plant work and the only way to get that is the quality of your process.
How clean are your clean rooms? How good is your manufacturing? How well mixed and pure are your inputs? And so, you know, we might have this notion that I think is very stuck in the past of perhaps things are lower cost and high scale, but low quality coming out of the Chinese industrial engine of 20, 30 years ago. That's not the story here. CATL is making and BYD are making the best quality cells in the world as well, which I think is a fascinating element of this.
It's a great point. I remember Bob impressing the sponsors. You can't be a battery manufacturer and scale unless your quality is top notch. Right. And we've seen this through the fires and through the issues. When you have an advanced manufacturing product, the driving down of the cost comes side by side with the driving up of quality.
Yeah. Well, let's talk about some of those attempts in the west to try and produce cells and battery packs at scale. Most notably, early on, Tesla 2014 makes this huge announcement. A $4 to $5 billion factory in Nevada that by 2020 will make more lithium-ion cells than the whole world made in 2013. A lot of people are like, this is a stupid idea. Let's just buy cells from Japan, let's buy cells from Asia. The world was not producing enough cells for what Tesla's ambitions were. So Panasonic puts a billion and a half into the project.
And a little counterintuitively at a Tesla Gigafactory, Tesla's not making battery cells. Panasonic is there making battery cells that are then going into a Tesla pack. And actually furthermore, Panasonic bought Sanyo. In this whole era they're using Sanyo coating lines, Panasonic winding machines, few hundred Japanese technicians and then a bunch of American workers to manufacture cells. And then those cells go to the other side of the building into the Tesla packs.
They got so many things right in this insane bet. But you mentioned those Japanese technicians. One of the things that we've seen through this story time and time again is it is the expertise of the engineers. And in order for the Gigafactory to succeed, which it did, it required Panasonic to be making those cells and it required Panasonic's expertise and engineers to be living in Reno, which we were told is one of the reasons why there's good sushi there.
Yeah, I haven't been to Reno since this Gigafactory scale. I want to go back now. Next time I'm there, I'm going to try and go find some good sushi.
Find some sushi.
And that's still up and running. But I think one unfortunate thing is at least it's been a bit of a one off. There's been some other attempts across the US but part of it is that point that you're making earlier and I about the supplier park. You still don't have the ecosystem of the mixer and the coater and the foil wrapper and all these various pieces that you're going to need to build the scaled campus that they have in China. That was arguably one of the biggest attempts in the U.S. i think over in Europe they wanted to build their own scaled plant as well.
Right.
Even bigger. See, Europe has the same worry. Its car batteries come from LG, Samsung and CATL and that's starting to look like a threat to its sovereignty, just as it does in the US. So Europe's approach is to build one plant and give it everything. Good chemistry, enough capital, secure customers, proven leaders, clean power and political support. It's a small scale copy of China's approach. But in Sweden,
everything's lined up right. They find the perfect founder. This guy Peter Carlsson, who had ran sourcing at Sony Ericsson for a while and then supply chain at Tesla. He knows the Asian supply chain and he's ready to go. Right. So he is the founder of Northvolt.
Seems perfect.
It's all going to happen. He chooses the city in northern Sweden in part because it has very cheap carbon free hydropower. So not only are we going to make these in Europe, but we're going to make the greenest battery cells in the world. Volkswagen, BMW, all of the big European automakers start putting their orders in. They have billions of dollars of contracts lined up to buy their cells. And in January 24th they raised a $5 billion green loan, the largest in Europe's history. Well, let's go build the factory. Northvolt goes and builds this first factory and a few factors come together that essentially put them into a death spiral.
The first is like any battery factory we've talked about initially coming out of the gate, their yields are not perfect.
You need those nine rounds of boxing. And you've got to plan for the fact that every battery plant starts terrible before it gets good. And that's why CATL has famously 3,600 control points per cell. They are measuring everything, x raying almost 30 measurements on every cell they manufacture.
In this type of business, I mean that's your whole margin, right? Like a kind of fully ramped CATL plant line is putting out. Something like 90 out of every 100 cells are good to go. And Northvolt is something like maybe 60 to 70 of the hundred cells. That's a very different margin profile of a business. The second point is they chose their location based on clean power. This is the upper north of Sweden. This is not a manufacturing hub where there's an existing battery industry. They have to go bring people out to this hard to reach place to be trained up.
So yes, it was good for the Power input, but from a knowledge, expertise and kind of industry co location it was even worse than Reno. And then the third point is one on timing. They're getting this up and running. They've bet big on NMC. They're selling to the European high end auto manufacturers who want energy density and have made the same bet that most of the in the US did. Meanwhile, the EV market in Europe starts to soften. Simultaneously Chinese LFP prices have cratered. And so you look at this whole situation and you have a plant that's not at full ramp in a hard to reach place, bet on a chemistry that's no longer clearly the dominant way to go.
And it goes south. November 2024, they file bankruptcy with only 30 million left in the bank.
The notion that like you can't build batteries in Europe or the west is the wrong conclusion, right?
Absolutely.
It's that Northvolt ran out of time and ran out of money before they could climb the necessary hill. You need to climb to do battery manufacturing at scale and get the yields that you need to get.
I think back to our boxing analogy. Don't go into the boxing match planning for two rounds, you gotta find your way to nine. And don't put your boxing match in Northern Sweden, put it in Vegas, you know, or, or
get the rumble in the jungle where there's the supply park.
You need people to show up. And so the answer to this problem in the US where we're worried about our auto industry, which is a huge part of our economy, is to put up walls. 2024, we pass 100% tariff on Chinese electric cars and a 25% tariff on Chinese cells. That's not a tariff on those companies. Those companies go build cells in Hungary and Thailand, which is what they do. But this gets to the supply chain risk and gets us back to the question of okay, we're going to make the cars here, Fine. What about the cells?
Well, fine, we're going to make the cells here. What about the lithium?
What about the graphite? These elements that go into every cell, all of this chemistry we've been talking about, it all comes from somewhere. That's why the battery story is spread out over dozens of countries. And it truly is a global story because the supply chain comes from somewhere.
Let's take an NMC battery that might be in our Volvo. The single biggest ingredient is graphite because the whole anode is made on graphite. Then you have 40 kg of nickel, you have 5 to 10 of cobalt, some manganese, copper and aluminum foil that you're actually putting all this material on and a few kilograms of lithium.
Yeah. And depending on the recipe of battery you choose, depends on where you have to go in the world. So if you're choosing a cobalt based cathode, you're going to the Congo on those nickel dominant cells. You've got to go to Indonesia or northern Russia. And these famous lithium-ion batteries we talk about all start to go back to the Atacama Desert in Chile, a place that gets less than 2 millimeters of rain every year. Coming out of the Atacama Desert is a company called SQM, which had been operating in the salt flats for a number of years and found that the brine that they were mining had less than half a percent of lithium.
So as the lithium market starts to grow, so does SQM. But lithium is incredibly resource intensive. So in the driest place on earth, it takes about 2 million liters of water to make a ton of lithium. And so obviously this is devastating to the communities and the indigenous communities that live there to the point where a famous slogan and their protests are we cannot eat batteries. They take the water and life goes on. But the lithium market is just so powerful, as we've seen. And so the mining continues, the drying continues, the impact on these communities is real.
The industry also starts to diversify and moves to Australia where they find rock based lithium.
And I think one thing that's interesting about this moment is China is building out its battery business. It's looking to consolidate the supply chain as well. Right. So they start buying up a lot of these mines. They bought up the majority of Australia's largest mine and a quarter of SQM, the company based in Chile.
Yeah. So great. All right. They're operating in Australia, they're finding rock based lithium. That's gotta be better. Not quite. The rock ore is roasted over a thousand degrees Celsius. It's cooled, it's mixed with sulfuric acid, it's heated again. So whether you're in the Atacama Desert or you're mining rocks in Australia, the lithium that's powering this revolution is coming at great cost to the communities that live around it and the climate. Cobalt's really interesting. Cobalt's actually a byproduct of copper and nickel mining.
But when the battery market starts heating up and cobalt is a critical ingredient, you've got to go to the copper cobalt belt of Congo's Katanga province. Now, Katanga has been a part of the world's battlegrounds before, whether it's King Leopold's Rubber uranium for the Manhattan Project. And the mining that's done in this region is incredibly manually intensive, even to this day. About 20% of Congo's cobalt is dug by hand. This is men and boys in tunnels 50 to 150ft deep with no support, no ventilation. You've got women carrying 100 pound sacks up the mountain to wash the ore.
And estimates that nearly half of the artisanal workforce are children. And these mines are makeshift artisanal mines. The tunnels are collapsing all the time. People are buried alive underneath.
Reminds us of the early coal mining stories of a couple hundred years ago. It's terrible.
It is. And so part of China's geopolitical strategy throughout the 2000s has been to secure the supply chain. So they go into a lot of these regions, like in the Congo, and offer up concessionary deals. Whether it's access to the minerals for roads and hospitals and railways and sports stadiums, much of that is never built. But you can be sure that the cobalt is mined and taken out.
And fortunately, cobalt has become less and less essential to our battery story over time. Right. We talked about that initial good enough lithium cobalt cathode, but then we got NMC and now we have LFP. And each step has made cobalt a less essential part of the chemistry story. Now, there is one exception. If you look at your iPhone and it has the densest battery possible from a space perspective, or your Apple Watch or your AirPods or your Samsung equivalents, it's pretty likely that's still a lithium cobalt chemistry.
Fortunately, there's now a big focus on using recycled cobalt. Supposedly, that's what Apple's done in a lot of their supply chain.
That brings us to the third main element in batteries that we've talked a lot about, which is nickel. Now, nickel has been used for centuries, the huge industry is stainless steel, and batteries were just a rounding error when it comes to the global nickel production. Until Tesla chooses that its battery source and Musk pleads with miners, please mine more nickel now. For decades, the best nickel in the world came from northern Siberia. Incidentally, a single smelter up there would emit more sulfur dioxide than all of Germany.
This is a very resource intensive and highly emitting production process. These days, about 60% of the world's nickel is coming from Indonesia. But you've got wastewater from this production and this smelting process going right into the sea around those islands. And that brings us to graphite, actually the biggest ingredient in the canister.
In the early 2000s, there's a switch from synthetic graphite to natural flake. And nearly all of this graphite is processed in China, supposedly. You can see the graphite sparkle like glitter in the sky. And there's dust on everything in the windows and the corn and the wheat near where these processing plants are in Shandong, farmers supposedly cannot sell their crops because not even the animals there would want to eat them after the graphite processing. So if you zoom out and you look at the supply chain, most of it is flowing through China in processing.
And so if you look at a battery that's got its anode and its cathode, China holds nearly 90% of the cathode material capacity and 97% of the anode capacity. It is the top refinery for 19 of the 20 energy minerals that the IEA tracks. And so even if you're making a cell in Japan or Korea or in the US or in Hungary or in Thailand, that's running on powder, that's coming through and out of China first. And so there's a real reckoning to be had as you move up and down the stack where different countries are willing to take supply chain dependencies to get their batteries.
But the other thing to I think, reflect on, on the mining point is just how we weigh one extractive industry against another and how do we think about those trade offs? And it's complicated and there's a lot of nuance to unpack. But I think one comparison that's illustrative to me at least, when we talk about the relationship between these minerals, the battery cells, and then eventually the cars that they're going to go power is how does it compare against other ways we might be getting that power into a car or into our energy system?
Well, it's still so much less digging than we do for fossil fuels, even once you count refining waste. So if you took all of the materials we think we need for the energy transition combined by 2050, it comes out to about six and a half billion tons again from now until 2050. That's against 8 billion tons of coal that we dig every single year. And so now back to the story of batteries. This whole period and this whole scale up in China ultimately fed into this learning law, often called Wright's Law. And this is one of the reasons that all the forecasters got it wrong.
In 2010, a lithium-ion pack cost around 1100 kilowatt-hour in China. Today, it's down to 84. And a stationary LFP pack, maybe 70 bucks. It was really a story about scale. The separators got thinner, the factories got bigger, the defect rate and the yield got better and better. Each doubling of production generally takes about a fifth off the price of the end product. And the EV industry that boomed in the last 15 years to kind of get this market off the ground enabled a massive scale of production to bring down the cost curve.
So we have a lot to reckon with around the future of the geopolitics. But I sit here very grateful that we've written down that learning curve and so that today, in 2026, we get to look at the next application of where we can scale up batteries.
Batteries on the Grid2007–today
So that wraps up our chapter on how China came to make most of the world's batteries. And now that we have all these abundant and cheap cells, it's time for the next story on the major development of batteries. Let's put some batteries on the grid. We're about to begin the transformation of our power grid via batteries. And by the way, this is all happening now, like in the last few years. This is the step change that we're living through. So to give you a sense of how fast and how dramatic, let's go to a beautiful California sunset.
It's the summer of 2020. A heat wave hits. The sun sets, solar power fades, but the air conditions keep running. California doesn't have enough power after dark, and so they order rolling blackouts. The first time in almost 20 years, half a million homes end up losing power. Fast forward six years later to 2026. Another sunset. But now the batteries have soaked up that midday sun and supply almost 40% of California's electricity. At Evening Peak, that's about 12 gigawatts or 6 Hoover dams coming from these boxes that didn't exist six years ago.
In just the last three years, we're regularly having moments in California and Texas primarily when batteries are the dominant supplier of power. Imagine that, like from nowhere to being the majority supplier of power, outperforming other power plants that have been around for decades because they are just the right application at the right time, at the right cost for the right need. So let's dig in to how we got to this moment and how batteries are changing the economics and physics of our energy system. Now, for those of you that listen to the grid episode, and if you haven't queue it up, you'll know that the grid has no storage tank.
Ever since Edison's Pearl Street switches on in Lower Manhattan, every watt of power has to be used in the instant that it's made. Supply and demand have to match every fraction of a second. The result is the supply capability has to be sized for the worst hours of the year.
So you always have to oversize, right?
You've got to meet every second of all of those days. And so you need the systems that can keep all of this in balance. It's magical, but it also has ramifications, from poor grid utilization to the inability to deploy a cheaper but more volatile energy source and the need to create complex markets to keep everything in balance.
And a battery helps with all of this. Of course, a rechargeable battery doesn't make any energy of its own, but it shifts in time when energy is generated to when it is consumed. It can fill up when power is cheap and plentiful and then discharge when there is peak demand. So on an average day, the grid runs at about half its max capacity. So moving energy into the peak gets more work out of the plants and wires and grid we already have, delaying the need to build more to serve that peak. To better understand how this impacts the energy market, let's do a little episode recap from the grid episode.
A quick re primer on what we mean when we're talking about balancing supply and demand on the grid. Let's start with that real time instant moment, the physical frequency of the grid. At any given moment, the entire connected grid is oscillating at that same 60 hertz together, the turbines are physically connected. And so when any load is added, when I turn on the light switch in my house or plug in an EV or we flip on some GPUs over in a data center, it physically pulls on all of those turbines. And when that load gets large enough, you have to adjust, you have to add a little bit more steam to the plant, you have to add a little bit more fuel to actually keep it all bounced so that you don't slow down too much.
This moment by moment correction that keeps the frequency in check is what we call frequency regulation. If you get this wrong, even by a couple hertz, there is complete and utter grid catastrophe. We actually just saw this last year in the EU. The EU grid happens to run at 50 hertz. And last April in Spain, there were some oscillations that caused a couple plants to trip offline. That caused there not to be enough supply online in that moment. And so the grid began slowing down and operating just 2 hertz off, 48 hertz instead of 50 hertz.
So that starts kicking load off and it leads into full blackout across Spain. It disconnects from its neighbor in France, Portugal, goes offline. It is complete Chaos, right? They have electric trains that are stuck with passengers on board. It takes until early the next morning for them to restart and get everything going again. And so we need a market to keep that all online.
It is mission critical to be able to manage the grid at a second by second. And that's just one of multiple jobs that batteries could be really well placed for. So let's think about three jobs for storage, immediate, medium and long term horizons. So the immediate job is the one Ben was just talking about, frequency regulation. Pushing power in and out within seconds to keep the grid at 60 hertz. You actually only need about 15 minutes of storage to do this job. Pretty well placed for a battery. The medium sized job is moving energy.
It's that charging when the power is cheap during the day and then selling when the power is expensive in the evening. And then we have the long term job, which is capacity. That's the biggest market that's being counted on to be power for the hardest hours of the year, the way a gas peaker plant is. And so for that a battery needs about four hours of power. There's a final job which we'll touch on later, which is really long duration. We're talking about a hundred hours. But we'll get to that in a moment. Let's start with the fast job.
This is where batteries enter the grid and start to go to work. And so with all the talk of EVs happening in the 2000s, those in the power business were, were asking themselves, well, what else could batteries do when they get to scale?
And so let's go back to 2007. Chris Shelton, CTO of AES, which is a company that owned and operated power plants, was sitting there and hearing all of these stories about how maybe one day we're going to have vehicle to grid. The idea that millions of EVs are going to be parked and we're going to charge and discharge on the utility operators command. He got interested, but looked around and again, if you listen to, you know, our story, and in 2007 there were not many EVs on the road, let alone being plugged in and managed as fleets.
But the cells were getting there. And so Chris decided to skip the car for now, go buy the cells, wire them into packs and install them at a substation. And his goal is to compete with the frequency regulation that a thermal plant does, which has valves and is oftentimes slow to respond and can cause issues. Whereas a battery, a digitally controlled battery, can respond instantly to a signal. And so you don't need a huge battery for this. Even just kind of 15 minutes of storage at a substation can provide that grid stability.
In 2008, they deploy the first real project, a 2 megawatt 500 kilowatt-hour lithium battery. Exactly 15 minutes if you're to discharge it straight into an Indianapolis substation. Four engineers build this by hand. They buy modules, power electronics, semi trailers, air conditioners, all separately and, and supposedly the air conditioners didn't arrive on time. So they went to Home Depot, bought some fans, and plunged them in to keep the batteries cool.
Right. The, the key was don't let these batteries catch fire. And it worked.
They tracked it and it followed that frequency regulation signal. It flipped on when it needed to, and it kept everything at that smooth 60 hertz.
And then we started to see more demonstrations. Late in 2009, AES actually goes and puts 12 megawatts of A123 cells next to a coal plant in northern Chile to cover the coal's reserve capacity. And so this may have been the first example of a battery making money on the grid by actually making a coal plant more valuable. A few years later, AES energizes Laurel Mountain, which was a wind farm with one of the largest lithium-ion battery installations in the world. These were cells meant for the Chevy Volt, now going on to grid applications at a meaningful amount of scale.
And it's right around this time that there's a realization that the market's not set up correctly. We're not actually paying for better performance. We're paying for these slow thermal plants to stay online for frequency response, for issues in order to fix this. And now batteries are being incentivized onto the grid with their superior faster frequency response performance.
So we're getting policy helping enable this market. And the AES team told us that it was at that Laurel Mountain site in West Virginia with the large lithium-ion battery installation that they realized that if a battery can serve this 15 minute need, why can't it go to four hours and actually replace the gas fired peaking plant? And why do they talk about four hours? Well, that's basically what an evening peaker plant serves. You come home, you flip on the tv, you, you fire up the oven, you turn on the lights, dishwasher's running all since the days of Samuel Insull.
You need power for these about four hours, which is actually how the rules have been written for gas turbines for decades. Resource adequacy only counts as capacity if it can deliver four hours straight.
And this is a Huge jump in scale. Right, because that 15 minute battery use in the frequency regulation is a fairly small amount of cells to actually like cover that small time window. This is a much bigger market if you're actually trying to absorb and then charge and discharge four hours of energy onto the grid.
And we're in the middle of the 2010s right now, so nobody's making a cell that can serve this need cheaply enough. A market that small can't drive lithium battery cost curves down to make it cheap enough to actually displace the gas peaker plant on a cost basis.
Just like we saw in the ramp up of EVs which are now cost competitive. We need the state, a state to create the conditions for a market to form a little bit ahead of the economics. Let's turn to California. Okay, so it's 2010 in California and a state law passes telling the state's utility commission to decide whether utilities have to buy energy storage and to make that decision within three years by 2013. And the motivation in this law is to create the conditions for renewable growth. They want more solar and wind to come on the grid and they want to avoid building more gas peaker plants.
The foundational law requires that a third of California's power comes from renewables by 2020. And a recognition that to achieve that we might need some energy storage and we need to drive utilities to go buy that storage simultaneously. Los Angeles has a separate problem. A state water rule was adopted in 2010 that was forcing old gas plants along the coast to close or at least rebuild because they cool themselves by pumping in seawater, which was harming the local marine life. And this actually has a massive effect.
This rule leads to nearly 5 gigawatts of plants in the LA basin needing to be shut down.
And so in an effort to address this problem, the utility commission actually orders to SoCal Edison to buy nearly two gigs of new capacity in Western LA over the coming years. Most of it's going to be gas, but there was a clause in there that at least 50 megawatts has to be storage. And 50 megawatts may not sound like much, but this is the first time an American regulator tells the utility to buy a specific amount of storage. State actor creating a market. And so the Edison team turn to themselves and they're like, well, we've looked at dozens of technologies and they're not sure if any of these are cost effective.
But the commission is trying to propagate a market in a reasonable and modest way.
Yeah, that's Right. They say go figure it out. Like it's only 50 megawatts, like go find a way to make it work. Meanwhile, our friends back at AES are getting frustrated. They're trying to sell battery projects as replacements to gas speaker plants. And they keep getting rejected proposal after proposal. Utilities are just not buying. You see, the utilities know how to buy a peaker plant. They've been doing it for decades. They don't know how to buy batteries. And if you go back to the incentives of utilities, let's remember that a regulated investor owned utility earns a return on capital that it owns.
So going and building out a owned gas plant pays back in a way that a battery contract does not. Now in all of this, the utility commission is hitting the deadline of that 2010 ruling to say what are they going to do across the state in the 2013 decision. It's the end of 2013 and they've been hearing from AES and they've been hearing the frustration that utilities are not buying even if it's economically rational for the consumer. The utility commission needs to incentivize demand. And so they rule that by 2020 they want to see over 1300 megawatts of storage in California.
And it works. The next year, SoCal Edison starts contracting major sites with AES. And it set the shape of the American product for the next decade. This four hour battery storage product that was being bought in place of that four hour gas plant.
And as we've seen before, one thing that catalyzes an early market is a Crisis. It's late 2015 and a well at the Aliso Canyon gas storage field right above Los Angeles starts leaking. It takes nearly four months to seal it. It releases over 100,000 tons of methane. The largest leak in US history moves thousands of families out of their homes. Now this Aliso Canyon gas field stores the power for LA summer evenings. And the state agencies see that if this gas field is offline, they're going to face massive shortages over the coming summer.
And there's no conventional technology that can be built fast enough. Except for one that is starting to emerge a few months later. The commission orders Edison to buy storage to be running by the end of the year. And there's one company that's ready to jump into action,
who moves fast and likes batteries.
For the past few years, Tesla had been prototyping their stationary battery business using old car parts, using model S battery modules, repackaging them, these 18650 laptop cells into stationary storage that could feed other needs and at this moment, there are no rules for connecting a battery like this. There are no testing procedures. Tesla's drafting the policies alongside the utility, but is determined to meet the need and demonstrate that their battery packs can actually mitigate this crisis on their hands.
I think utilities were like, what is this thing? Is it load or is it a generator? And they're like, I guess if I have to choose, it's a generator. It doesn't quite spin, so I don't know a box to check there,
but we'll pretend like it spins and, oh, you only need it to be responsive in 15 minutes. It's actually responsive instantly, but we'll say 15 minutes,
like, what do we have to do to get through the application?
And so Tesla's one of a number of companies that responds to this emergency. And by the end of the year, you've got over half dozen emergency projects running, all battery powered.
And I think an amazing part of this is, like, how fast they were. These projects were built in less than 100 days from contracting. And so this is back to this initial push of like, we're not going to be able to build a peaker plant in that time.
There's no way.
These are modular, manufacturable things. We have plenty of cells now in the US from the EV supply chain. Like, let's package these up and put them on the grid.
Yeah. And something was happening. This wasn't the only disaster driving markets.
In 2016, a huge storm knocked out 23 transmission towers in South Australia. The whole region loses power, almost a million customers, and within hours, it's a political disaster. The government is blaming the wind farms. All this debate ensues about how to make the grid more resilient again. Tesla says we can jump in and save the day and build this quick. And so the co founder of Atlassian, who's based in Australia, tweets to Elon Musk, how serious are you about this bet? I can make the money and the politics happen.
Can you guarantee a hundred megawatt battery in a hundred days? And Musk says Tesla will get the system installed and working 100 days from contract signature or it is free. That serious enough for you?
Boom. Mic drop.
The project signs with Tesla In September and 63 days later, it is built and deployed in live 100 megawatts turned on the Hornsdale Power Reserve. And in the first year, this Battery saves ratepayers 40 million Australian dollars. And the price of frequency control in the state plummets by more than a factor of 10.
These rapid deployments end the argument about whether batteries can do the job. It's all about economics. And that is a much easier argument to win over time.
Where's the best place to test economics?
One good place is where the free market reigns and new technologies can pop up just because they are more cost effective. Let's go down to Texas.
ERCOT has no capacity market that's paying generators just to sit there and wait. It only has the market for actually buying and selling energy. The energy market.
So having a market that only earns money when they sell power is a great place to test batteries. Right? You charge up the battery and power is cheap. Sell it when the power spikes. And Texas is a market that is very familiar with power spikes. Remember winter storm Uri in 2021. We were minutes away from the entire grid collapsing. So it's a visceral feeling and a need to mitigate those types of disasters. And now the battery is able to do this four hour shift. We can actually shift that duck curve from the afternoon to the evening.
The other benefit is it's also really fast to build an ERCOT. They don't operate with the same federal regulation and they connect projects that are ready on a kind of a first come, first serve basis. And so utility scale battery project will take one and a half to two and a half years. In California we're talking four to six years.
So shockingly quickly the Texas grid got rid of those spikes. So by the start of this year 2026, Texas had about 14 gigawatts of batteries. And so the Texas battery market has gone completely vertical. California has the strong policy tailwinds and these real problems that needed storage solutions. But I think when many of us think about the intersection of batteries in the grid, I don't know that the first image is container sized batteries out in the middle of nowhere hooked up to transmission lines. I think the first thing we'd experience is where we'd all interface with it.
Let's think about that box in the garage.
It's 2015 and Tesla unveils the Powerwall, the battery built for the home. And what's amazing is that Tesla's early sales teams are watching customers buy this largely because like I just want to have it. I just feel like I need it. They're spending tens of thousands of dollars on batteries that they'll use once a year. Economics don't pencil, but think of this as the Roadster of home batteries. Right? They're starting up market knowing that the bigger market is when it makes economic sense and Those economics are taking some time, but it's emerging and some things catalyze it.
In 2019, PG&E cuts off power to about two and a half million people to keep its lines from starting another fire. And reports show several hundred homes riding through the outage based on their batteries. But then the big change comes. In 2023, California introduces what's called Nem 3.0, which changes the incentive structure to make it way more economical and profitable to consume your own power. That year alone, batteries added to Solar Homes grow 6x
installers. Talk about being like a difference of defaults. Prior to this, maybe 10, 20% of people who gain a solar system are like, oh yeah, let me add a battery after this. It's like, you don't get a solar system without a battery. It completely flips it on its head.
And this continues to drive the market. Tesla passes a million Powerwalls sold and we start to approach almost 3 gigawatts of batteries being installed in homes in a single year. And so what started out as kind of an individual backup system for resilience and a nice to have starts to become much more about economics. But the economic story benefits from not just an analysis of your own power bill, but also the impact to the grid and the utilities incentives to leverage these new battery packs that exist out there.
We chatted with Justin Lopas, the co founder of Base Power, and he had a great way of framing this. If you have 100 homes and 50 of them have batteries, the peak amount of electricity that needs to be transmitted through the entire system is only 50 homes worth, not a hundred. So you need less poles and wires and you can power more homes without upgrading the system. Now we start talking about an incentive structure that affects an entire neighborhood or the utility catchment area.
And this is a big deal. As we think about this whole affordability moment and bills, this whole cost of the distribution system, I think it's the fastest growing part of an electricity bill.
Absolutely. You can see it right on your bill. And this isn't just happening here. I recently learned that in Australia they've deployed close to half a million home battery systems in the last year because it is such an effective mechanism to stabilize the grid, provide resilience to people, while also avoiding these massive upgrades that will take time and a lot of money.
And I think the other super interesting element of this is not just the physical deployment, but what is the software orchestration layer that sits on top of all of this to coordinate it. You don't just plug a battery into the wall. And all of a sudden it's doing exactly what you want it to do. You have to tell it.
It's got to know what to do, when to do it, how to do it, how fast to do it, when to shut off.
It's like an ant in a battery colony across the grid. And so we're starting to see enough scale that it matters. Just this last summer, Sunrun, RenewHome and Tesla came together and announced the plan to combine hundreds of thousands of home battery systems to build the largest distributed power plant in the country. This totals up to over 16 gigawatts of electricity across homes and utility scale plants. This is 12 million devices in 9 million homes. And so you're thinking about how to coordinate all of that to actually bid into the energy markets and become the scaled system.
We're finally seeing this confluence of factors of demand. The aging grid technology that's affordable and now being deployed at scale enough that we can actually use it in what's called a virtual power plant or a distributed energy resource, where you don't have to necessarily build a new power plant to create more power onto the grid.
And it's an area that's like so ripe for invention. What are the protocols? What are the market designs? How is this all working? How do you sit between someone who wants to get credit for that electricity and someone who wants to supply it? This is like, I think, probably the most dynamic part of the power market that we've seen.
And it exists largely due to decades of innovation and manufacturing excellence that has brought the cost down to make these applications affordable.
That's right.
An unaffordable battery is good to know one.
Yeah, and policy has helped here too. Right? You have various policies, state policies that are creating economic incentives. The Inflation Reduction Act in 2022 gives a major 30% tax credit to all these battery systems that we only saw prior on solar systems. And so, so there's just this tailwind after tailwind to the economics of deploying grid scale and home scale battery systems.
We've got another major tailwind that is driving demand for energy in very concentrated places that just might prove to be yet another beautiful application for the battery on the grid. Data centers are obviously the biggest news story and the biggest new load coming on the grid very aggressively. And it matters for a number of reasons. But one of the most important reasons is because, remember, we're coming off of two decades of relatively flat growth for electricity in the United States. So we're not used to putting on a lot of new load or capacity onto the grid very quickly.
These data centers are extremely large power draws, but they're also very localized, and we're trying to get them online incredibly fast, which sounds like yet another potential application for the battery.
There's three significant system design reasons that batteries matter when we think about data centers, and they kind of mirror the markets we talked about in the general grid, but have some unique components when we think about data centers. First, you have really fast shock absorption. Second, you have the need for resilience in your expensive data centers and chips. And third, you have the need for capacity to actually enable us to build out the data centers in places where we maybe didn't think we had enough power.
And so let's start with that first one. What do we mean about shock absorption and shocks to the grid? Well, for scale, a major AI data center is the equivalent consumption, or more than than a large city's power draw concentrated in a single location. Now, if that isn't enough, the way that the training runs can run can be very spiky. There's this moment called a checkpoint, where all of the GPUs update their weights in unison, and the power can go from running at full load to dropping to zero, near zero in a millisecond.
This can drive that frequency regulation completely crazy. It's an immense scale,
and we've seen the strain on the grid when everyone just turns on their air conditioners at the same time. Imagine all the power fluctuating.
That's right. The hyperscalers are aware of this. There's a paper put out by Microsoft, OpenAI, and Nvidia just last summer that said if the swings start to resonate with the grids, they can cause physical damage to the power grid structure. We're talking to someone in the data center industry, and they said it would be absolutely devastating to the industry. Like you think. There's a lot of backlash against data centers in the power grid. Now, imagine if they caused a catastrophic outage that lasted hours or days.
And so how do batteries come in and save the day? Well, batteries are the perfect buffer here. You put a battery somewhere between the racks and the grid, and you can start to buffer those swings and have the battery kind of be the shock absorber.
Yeah, these batteries are built to respond in milliseconds, which is exactly the timing of these swings.
One example is a company called Heron Power. They put a transformer and a battery together near the racks. That converts the grid's AC power into the DC power that the chips actually run on. And the battery soaks up those GPU swings. There are also versions of this for the whole site. Every data center already has some protective buffer. It's called a UPS or an uninterruptible power supply. It's a bank of batteries that keeps the servers running until the backup generators can start. A company called onergy builds what's basically a UPS for the whole campus.
It sits between the grid and the data center and buffers in both directions.
Another form of shock absorption is flexibility, particularly leveraging the batteries that sit quote unquote behind the meter, perhaps in those homes we talked about or elsewhere. Because if the grid needs to supply the maximum amount of power that people are going to use and they can't build enough of that new peak demand, it would be super helpful for a large load like a data center to not make those peaks peakier. Right. Don't add to the problem of the peak loads, or as the industry likes to call it, curtail their peak load.
And the famous Duke study found that we have over 100 gigawatts of headroom if we can just subdue those peaks for a few hours a year. And so what are data centers doing to not be a bigger problem to the peak load? Well, they're able to install batteries and curtail that peak load while still continuing to run their chips and make their money. So your clod chats can still continue running off of a battery even if it's in an evening peak load moment. It's a great application for a battery similar to the home, but on a much, much larger scale.
And as a result, this market is going through the roof. It's now the second largest stationary storage market globally.
And then we have the biggest problem of all, which is like we maybe just don't have enough capacity on the grid for the scale of data centers we want to hook up. The third application is actually using batteries to count as capacity on the grid, even if it's not co located with the data center. But the data center builder wants to bring that capacity as essentially the fastest power plant it can build. You know, let's remember, gas turbines are sold out. There's like a five to seven year backlog. Who wants to wait five to seven years to plug in their GPUs?
Meanwhile, as we talked about, you can do a grid scale battery project in Texas in 18 months. So this is just a faster way to get more gigawatts on the grid. And this fits exactly into a framework you might hear in the power data center story, which is bring your own capacity deals, which says, okay, data center developer, if you show up and you want to build a gigawatt data center, and if you can bring a gigawatt of power with you, we'll let you get built. So many of those are saying, yes, we will do this and we'll bring that in the form largely of batteries because that's going to be the fastest way to energize that load.
Good example of this is a 1.4 gigawatt data center that Oracle is building in Michigan and they're doing exactly this. They're matching that 1.4 gigawatts with an equivalent massive amount of batteries. And speaking of capacity, this is a great moment in our story to thank our sponsor, Crusoe. Crusoe is the vertically integrated AI company and that includes how they power their sites. They look at each campus as a whole and work out the best mix of energy resources to bring power into it. And that has put them at the forefront of deploying batteries.
In March, they announced a 12 GWh project with Form Energy as part of a bring your own capacity deal and they're working to bring it online in 2027. We'll be getting into Form's iron–air long duration battery later in the episode because that's very cool. And just this last summer, Crusoe's project with Redwood Materials became the largest second life battery project in the world. It pairs solar with retired EV battery cells, and they built the first phase in just under four months to power a set of their modular data centers called Crusoe Spark units.
We spent time with Crusoe's energy team and they're deploying proven lithium-ion and new long duration technology side by side. Data centers need capacity fast and batteries are now cheap enough to supply a lot of it. When projects like these work, the entire industry benefits from that. If you want to learn how Crusoe approaches energy in the grid, head to Crusoe AI Stepchange. Thank you, Crusoe, for your partnership.
And of course, there's an interesting nuance here because a battery is not a gas plant, right? They can't just keep running indefinitely. We need to charge the batteries up from the grid at night or in midday when other plants have power to spare, and then discharge them back into those peak moments. So the grid operators give every kind of power plant a score based on a calculation for the hardest days of the year. How much of its rated nameplate capacity can we count on? So in pjm, the power market for The Northeast.
Most of these hardest hours are now in the winter cold snaps. A gas turbine gets a score of 60% because in deep cold, some can't get the fuel or they break down. A four hour battery scores 50% because the cold snap can last longer than the four hours and the battery runs dry. A 10 hour battery scores 72%. And this PJM capacity market has gone through a crazy auction recently. In the last couple years, it jumped from $30amegawatt day to over 300 because of all the data center load growth. So this is an extremely appetizing market to go build batteries and deploy to bring your own capacity for.
And this is great for batteries because every market that they're entering is bigger than the last arbitrage market was bigger than frequency regulation. The capacity market is way bigger than anything before. This is why we believe we're in the earliest innings of this technology revolution.
So now across these markets and across data centers, we're putting out a ton of these battery cells. What could go wrong?
You've got cells in cars, cells in people's pockets, cells in buildings, cells on the grid. Each one of these battery installations and each one of these new pack designs and new applications create a risk for the bane of a battery's existence, which is a fire. And it's especially problematic when it's adjacent to the person, which is why Japan's manufacturing revolution of the 90s was so incredible. You needed your Sony Walkman or camcorder on your body. You couldn't have any risk. It's also really problematic when you have tens of thousands of cells sitting in a community.
The worst story of this happened in Moss Landing in California, a community on the coast of Monterey Bay. So there's a power plant there with a couple 500 foot smokestacks that PG&E built in the 1950s to burn oil and gas. Over the decades, it's changed different owners, and ultimately it belongs to Vistra, a Texas power company. Well, a few years ago, Vistra opened a battery system inside one of these old turbine buildings. 300 megawatts at the time, the largest battery in the world. And it felt like a symbol of moving from gas to batteries, given where it was located.
By 2023, that system had more than doubled inside the old plant. And next door, PG&E builds another system of Tesla Megapacks. Outside. In January of 2025, a fire started inside that building and one of the batteries went into thermal Runway. The problem was that the heat spread to all the other batteries around it. And there wasn't any separation to stop it. The fire went on burning for days. Hundreds of people were evacuated. Highway 1 was shut down. And as a result, heavy metals and toxins have been scattered into the soil all across the neighborhood.
And then just a few weeks ago, another 1200 damage modules caught fire again. And so it's really problematic to have this massive demonstration project, hundreds and hundreds of megawatts of batteries inside a gas plant catching fire when right next door, Tesla's batteries had a fire of their own. Same chemistry, nickel, manganese, cobalt. But because they sat outside and they were separated into different cabinets, the fire stayed in one cabinet and didn't spread.
And I think this gets to maybe one of the core lessons from the Moss Landing battery catastrophe, which is more about the design of the system than the batteries themselves. The entire industry has moved to these outdoor containers that have physical separation and isolate any potential runaway into one container. And also the whole industry has moved to a lower burning chemistry, our friend lithium iron phosphate, or LFP, which wins simply on cost, but also has this added benefit of being much less likely to cause a high temperature fire.
Now, I don't want to be an apologist for this battery industry disaster, but I think it's also worth giving some context. When we look at the history of energy systems, we take it for granted that it's safe to put a tanker of gasoline on the freeway, or pump it down underground under our gas stations, or put it into our car. It took years and decades for the petrol tank to become this reliable engineered system the way it is. And batteries at this scale are a very new thing, and they're rapidly evolving. So just in the five years from 2018 to 2023, the failure rate of cells dropped 97%.
That means if you look at a gigawatt scale deployment, you used to have nine incidents, and one of those could lead to this Moss Landing fire. Now you have 0.2. And so, from every level, from the cell manufacturing through to the design and containment of potential runaway, we've made immense engineering progress in real time.
And the reason this failure rate is so critical for the battery industry is not just to keep their batteries online, but it's to maintain the image of batteries. If you have fires emerging in different battery plants, you're going to start to lose local permission. You're going to start to lose the permission to install batteries in a particular neighborhood, which would be super detrimental to the industry.
And it's happening. There are over 100 active moratoriums. Now, these aren't outright Bans. But these are delays on battery projects, particularly in New York, Washington state, where I am, and in California where cities and local governments are saying we're going to wait to allow any battery storage projects to be deployed. While I think some of this questioning is fair, like I think it's really important that anyone involved in this looks at the progress we've made in technology and we actually like, size the risk accordingly alongside the other risks.
We've gotten so used to the gas plant next door that's polluting the air or the coal plant that it's not like we question that with nearly the same level of concern that we might be with a modern, safe, LFP containerized battery park in 2026. So if we just zoom out for a moment and reflect on where we are in the deployment of batteries into our grid and energy system, we're in such a, an immensely exciting moment. This is the first time that it's become economical to really store electricity where you use it and to reshape the entire kind of physics and time consumption patterns of the grid at scale.
It feels like we're really living through this transformation of how we think about the topology of the grid.
And it really is this early innings, metaphorically after personal devices and vehicles, we found an application in this frequency regulation and shock absorption. That was a small but important market. Then we moved into four hours in energy arbitrage, which is still a very exciting and growing market. And now we're moving into the capacity markets, which is a multi hundred billion dollar energy system. It's here we see batteries continue to find new markets, policies being introduced to create those pathways and costs coming down to make them more and more competitive against a fossil fuel source.
Back to that point that we heard about with the early Tesla departments, which is like we still don't quite know. And the market still doesn't quite know how to treat batteries because they have the potential to be an inversion of the topology of the grid from this clear hub and spoke model to one where electricity can be stored up and localized in buckets and then shifted across time. And I think when you think about it that way, it becomes much more part of the new infrastructure of the grid aligned with maybe we don't need to necessarily always supercharge the distribution or transmission grid in this moment.
If we put storage on both sides of that, that is not quite capacity markets, it's not quite energy markets, it's something new entirely. It's the market for storage. We're in the moment of shaping that market and seeing how things evolve now that it's becoming a real player at scale.
And it really is taking shape right now and happening really fast. In five days, we will install the equivalent of all of the grid storage capacity that existed 10 years ago. Like, this market is very new. The applications have yet to be found, as you just mentioned. And so it really is a
step change call on
What About…Recycling, sodium, long duration
really is a step change moment. So as we researched this episode, we kept running into questions. What about recycling? What about sodium-ion? What is this long duration thing we keep hearing about? So we wanted to create some space to answer some of the big questions we kept running into. It's a quick round of what abouts and we'll start at the end. What happens to a lithium-ion battery when it dies?
The initial EV promise was really twofold. It was, hey, we're gonna have zero emissions and zero waste. Yet after billions of lithium-ion cells shipped since the first ones in the early 90s, lithium-ion recycling barely existed when the EV market kind of came to the beginning in 2010. Now, the case for recycling is pretty simple. A dead lithium-ion pack holds more metal per pound than any unprocessed ore out of our mine. And that metal has already been mined, refined, shipped, and sitting in a country that maybe needs more of that supply.
It's almost like you think of a battery as an above ground mine.
That's exactly right. It's just sitting there. Now, unlike a tank of fuel, nothing is burned. An EV carries 460 pounds of critical minerals against maybe 70 pounds in a gasoline car. And they're all still sitting there at the end of the battery's life. Battery demand is doubling every two to three years. And batteries are now driving most of the world's lithium demand. On top of that, as we already discussed, China is refining almost all of the raw material. And that means if we don't do something to use the cells already in the country, we're going to keep needing to go back to China for new cells.
So if you're a country consuming billions of cells, but you don't mine or refine the metals, then the old batteries are your domestic source. Recovering the metal is solved. Right? We can get 80 to 95% of critical metals, depending on what you're talking about. But the metal inside is only worth what you can sell it for. So ironically, every time you have battery prices drop and lithium prices drop, it makes the cost of recycling harder to justify because you get less for it. The other challenge you run into is just where we are in the life cycle of batteries, we had this massive scale up of production in the late 2000 and tens and now in the last five years.
So those batteries haven't died yet. Because you think about an EV, that pack's life is eight to 15 years. So all of the recycling feed that we have today is actually factory scrap, not dead cars. If you think about JB Straubel, Tesla's CTO who founds Redwood Materials in 2017, they actually had to start with electronics and copper scrap because there weren't enough dead EV packs to begin to recycle.
And the other big story on recyclability of materials here is the chemistry change. Right. A lot of these recycling plants were stood up when everyone thought lithium cobalt or lithium nickel, manganese, cobalt. That has a lot of both lithium and these cathode materials that were going to be really valuable. As we increasingly move to LFP, iron phosphate is not really worth recovering maybe a third of the value from a materials perspective. Now the other big realization is that when we say that a battery pack in a car is dead, often it means that maybe the life of the entire pack is down perhaps from 100% to 80%.
Dead is a overly strong word here. And if you are willing to take out those cells and kind of test them one by one and reuse them for something else, they as individual cells can have an immense secondary life. And so instead of recycling, I think we're seeing the market increasingly shift to reuse. And that has immense value both for the NMC cells, but also for the LFP cells. And so Redwood Materials is actually starting to do this and it has a big data center battery deployment, I think with Crusoe using this principle, also much less energy and chemically intensive to do this.
Before you go to the end state of recycling.
The challenges before us are one of logistics. It's not as much a chemistry question as is a coordination and market question, which seems promising and one that we hope to solve.
Yes, absolutely. So what about pumped hydro?
So we may have mentioned that the grid has essentially no storage, but that was kind of a lie because there's something called pumped hydro and it's still actually the biggest grid storage asset that America has. It's roughly 90% of the US long duration storage. Why is that? Well, for over a century, one way to store energy was to pump water up a mountain, hold it there and then release it when you needed it. And nothing came close to this level of capacity. The problem was you had a trade off of power and Speed and a limitation geographically of where you could do this.
But I think you've got a lot of this up there in Seattle, don't you Ben?
Yeah. You know when you got, when you got a lot of water
and you got some hills,
that's all you need. But more than half of the operating fleet dates back to kind of this period around the 70s when we're trying to soak up the overnight baseload surplus from nuclear and coal plants and then sell it into the afternoon peak. Now, most of the prime pumped hydro locations have now been mapped and built out. So building more is more and more expensive and slower and slower to get approved and built. Other thing is kind of in this vein of like using gravity, right. As a energy storage has been tried as well, or other mechanical storage techniques.
So you had a flywheel plant in New York, there was a 20 megawatt plant that was being used for frequency regulation. You had gravity elevators trying to be proposed of like let's lift a big concrete block in a building and then drop it down. All of these types of projects and pumped hydro included do suffer from essentially being the opposite of learning curves. Right. This is the thing that we saw in the history of nuclear plants and other large scale infrastructure projects where they've gotten more expensive over time.
We've kind of atrophied our ability to learn. That's then competing against batteries, which are this beautiful smooth example of cheaper and cheaper at more and more scale. And so as such, batteries have just in the last couple of years crossed in the US Definitely not the energy capacity yet, but they're now almost 2x the power capacity of all of our pumped hydro. And the energy capacity will cross and get there at some point. But what about long duration batteries? We talked about lithium ion taking over the, the four hour segment.
What about other chemistries that can go for longer periods of time?
Well, it's interesting. Storage has one obvious limitation, which is its duration. You think about a gas turbine and as long as it's connected to a pipeline, you can run that puppy forever. There's no chemical reason why lithium can't do long duration. It's fundamentally a cost question. And with lithium, there's a little bit of a problem because every extra hour of discharge roughly costs the price of those extra cells. So it's kind of a linear function. So a utility is happy to pay for four hours because the cost is there.
But if you want 100 hours, you're essentially adding 25 times the cost and nobody's going to pay for that, which is why the alternative has been gas plants. So it's probably not lithiumion batteries, but there are alternatives. And one company going after this is called Form Energy. Now, what's interesting about Form is they went after duration first and then the chemistry second. And after modeling decades of weather data and energy markets, they found a tremendous amount of value, obviously at four hours, but even out to 10 or 12 hours when you're having that full daytime shift, and then very little value up until about 75 hours.
75 to 100 is when you start displacing a gas plant. Right. You're getting up to four days of power. And so with that hundred hour goal, they revisited an old technology called Iron Air, where you're essentially using the rust reaction to create current. Now, there's lots of pros and cons to the chemistry, but the market is there, especially when you think about data centers that need to byoc bring your own capacity to get online. So it's an exciting place to be and definitely worth pursuing. But it really fundamentally comes down to can that cost beat the alternative.
And they have to manufacture and build a whole new way of building these things. These are not the same as battery cells that we're used to, so it's quite an endeavor. Another interesting attempt is what's called flow batteries, which is a kind of fundamentally different physical design to the battery. In a flow battery, the energy sits in two tanks of liquid and the power comes out from a stack that the liquid is pumped through. So all you need to do to buy more hours of duration is get some bigger tanks and more liquid.
The chemistry that's won out is called vanadium and it's on both sides of the membrane. It's super, super durable and it has no risk of a volatile reaction causing a fire. Right. So you can put a flow battery right underneath the transmission line or inside of a data center and you're not worried about it exploding or causing thermal runaway.
Amazing.
Guess where the largest deployment of a flow battery is?
I'm going to think somewhere halfway across the world.
Yep, as in all energy markets, it's the largest energy energy buyer China. So Rongke Power has over three and a half gigawatt hours deployed, including one large single 200 megawatt flow battery. Why isn't the grid filled with flow batteries like it? Sounds great. Couple problems. First is as LFP prices continue to come down, it's not beating lithium on that kind of six to eight hour range where LFP is starting to creep up in longevity and Similar issue that Form is hitting the market hasn't really quite been fully designed to value this duration yet.
It's not like the four hour capacity market where we've designed the actual market structure to really fund these. Round trip efficiency is an issue. That's how much of the electricity you put in they're going to get back out. LFP batteries give back around 90%, but a flow battery is more like 70, 75%. And then you're flowing liquids. So you have moving parts, you have pumps, you have tubes, you have leaks. And the supply chain for all of this is still somewhat bespoke and volatile. So the price of vanadium can whipsaw back and forth, which makes all of these projects harder to finance.
So you compare that against this super mature CATL driven LFP supply chain and it's hard to underwrite to the same scale. But it does hold some promise for some grid scale applications. So what about sodium ion?
So when we think about affordability, duration and abundant materials, sodium ion has been talked about quite a bit.
The closer I get to it, I think the more exciting it is because the only thing that feels more LFP than LFP is sodium ion. Right? A lot of the same principles play out. And so as lithium prices in particular start to spike in the early 2000 and twenties, CATL unveils their first sodium ion product. Now, a few properties of sodium ion that I think are particularly interesting from a user's perspective. One is that sodium ion is cheaper, it's a cheaper supply chain. Sodium comes from soda ash or sodium carbonate. The US happens to be the world's largest producer of natural soda ash.
It's a good hedge against the lithium supply chain. But also just functionally, sodium ion works at much lower temperatures. You know, this is one of the annoying issues with lithium ion and one of the reasons that we still have lead acid batteries in our EVs. In a worst case scenario, you need to heat up those lithium ion cells and keep them warm enough to be able to operate sodium ion. They can operate in freezing temperatures. So our two big behemoths in China, CATL and BYD, start building large factories. And CATL recently just launched its sodium ion line which starts to compete actually with LFP.
And just this year the first Chinese EV was announced that will be a mass produced car using CATL's sodium ion cells and have a 400 kilometer range and over 90% capacity at negative 40 degrees Celsius. So it's an amazingly resilient, durable battery in the cold the trade off, of course, is that it holds less energy for its weight than LFP. And the relative cost advantage is very dependent on lithium prices. So when lithium prices crashed around 2022, it got a lot harder for sodium to win. Drama on cost. Still, I think sodium ion holds a lot of promise.
So we've talked about long duration. Where are we in the world of higher density batteries?
We love dense light batteries. Almost every answer to high density runs through lithium metal as the anode. So lithium metal holds about 10 times as much charge as graphite in today's cells. But remember that Moli cell fire. Lithium metal goes needles, which is why it shorted and burned the phones. And that's why lithium ion was the workaround back in the 90s. The high density opportunity is an attempt to revisit that. And there's two approaches here. Solid state is one approach.
Ah, the dream of solid state batteries.
The holy grail.
How do those work?
Replace the flammable liquid electrolyte with a solid wall that lithium can't pierce. The catch is that liquid is forgiving. A solid cell has nothing soft, nothing self correcting. And the problem is that with every charge the lithium layer grows and every discharge it shrinks and the needles start to form anyway. So this has been the perennial problem. It's really great in R and D, but it's extremely hard to manufacture this incredibly smooth surface that remains smooth through hundreds and thousands of cycles. Lithium sulfur is another approach that you might hear about, which is interesting because sulfur is super abundant and cheap.
It's essentially a waste product. And what you're doing is essentially having the lithium chemically react with the sulfur, which creates a much lighter battery. With no nickel, no cobalt and no graphite. It's easier to manufacture. You don't have the risk of fires. The problem is because the sulfur is reacting inside of the cell. You only get a few cycles before that battery cell wears down. But what application needs a very light battery and only a few dozen or 100 cycles?
Maybe something that flies like drones. You know, funny full circle moment. One of the leading companies in lithium sulfur is buying all of Northvolt's distressed assets. We're hopefully going to get a second life out of all of the factories in Europe that were built out for Northvolt.
Let's hope there's for better or for worse, a massive, fast growing market since the start of the Ukraine war. And the changes in defense tech have led to a huge opportunity for lithium sulfur. And the question probably remains is where can this chemistry and Engineering evolve to to have more use cases beyond drones used in war.
Maybe we'll see it like the really significant evolution of the disposable cells that the invention of improvements in World War II led to massive better consumer products with a lot more energy. Let's hope so. Further out, there's a family of batteries called metal air, like lithium air and sodium air. They work the same way that jet fuel does. They carry only one side of the reaction and then they can pull in oxygen from the air for the other side. That can mean several times the energy per pound of today's best packs.
But for now they're still very much in the lab cells.
So for our final what about we talk a lot about cars and mentioned trucks and buses. But if batteries are good for mobility, can we use them across the sea? Can we use them in the air? What about aviation and shipping?
Yeah, so flying planes takes a lot of energy. You know, jet fuel carries something like 12,000 watt hours a kilogram. And you know, the best pack in a car is something like 250. However, like the consumer and customer demand is intense. If we could electrify flight, like, imagine what that means, both for emissions but also for cost. So a new company, Hart Aerospace, just demoed a passenger plane flying for 30 minutes on battery power. This was the largest battery powered plane ever demonstrated.
The cost to power this thing was astounding. How much did it cost to power the flight?
Looks like it was $5. Can you imagine if your flight just cost, you know, a few bucks, $5 divided by 27 passengers. The energy is free. And so you can imagine people want this. It's backed by $10 billion in customer commitments lining out the door, including United Airlines and Air Canada. So this is the market where essentially we need to figure out can those lithium sulfur batteries, can we find improvements to drive up both the energy density and the cycle time? If so, I think this is an immense market potential and there are a lot of people who thought we'd never see electrified flight, but it might be around the corner.
And the key is short duration, short haul, right? Like we're not trying to fly from LA to London on electric jet anytime soon. But how about LA to San Diego?
Maybe LA to Seattle? Come on, come visit me, man. So where are we shipping batteries? Essentially, we've started to electrify some serious fleets of ferries and we have fully electric ferries that are scaling up. We still have a long way to go before we can electrify the shipping industry. But fortunately, if batteries succeed, we're going to only need about half the ships we have now because so much of global shipping is moving fossil fuels around as is.
Aha. The irony,
the irony. What about trucking?
Trucking's an incredibly interesting market. And again, we're not talking about long haul freight. We're not trying to get from LA to New York with electric trucks. We're talking about short haul. Where can you get cost parity against diesel truck on a 250 mile run? That's possible. In fact, one of our portfolio companies, Navoya, is finding route after route and they can beat diesel on these runs. Their demand is infinite. And so there is a tremendous potential for short haul trucking to be fully electrified, which not only has all of the benefits of cost and carbon, but a lot of short haul trucks run through low income communities and create a tremendous amount of pollution and noise that can be eradicated.
When we electrify,
it's a win, win, win. Except for the oil companies, I guess they lose.
We like that.
All right, well, that is the story of batteries
up until today. Because as we know it's, it's still unfolding.
Themes & CloseTakeaways
That's right. That is the beginning of the story of batteries. We should say for new listeners what we like to do now is zoom out and look like, what are our big takeaways from the story? What do we think we might want to remember and hold on to? What did we learn across that wild journey?
What have we been saying at dinner parties that everyone leans in on?
I think one of the biggest things, and definitely came up a lot in a lot of our interviews with folks, is an appreciation that there isn't some holy grail particular battery, battery chemistry, battery shape and size. That's going to be like the battery. For all that. There will be a diversity of chemistries and configurations and sizes and scales that are going to fit different applications. Because we're going to use batteries in many different ways and shapes and forms and that will naturally lend itself to different trade offs from energy density to cost to supply chain.
And so many of us associate batteries with the batteries that we touch directly, the AAS, the AAA's, the 9 volt battery. But that is a minority of the role that batteries are playing in our lives. In our lives. It's like the devices that we actually touch, the phone, the laptop, your car, any interaction with the grid is now touching batteries in some way. And those are all a little bit like invisible to us because they're all rechargeable.
Now you start looking around your house and your life and you start seeing batteries everywhere. It is pervasive and yet we are still in the earliest innings. And so it is only going to be more and more prevalent. But like all great infrastructure is also growing in invisible ways. And so it will be increasingly taken for granted as time goes on.
Which means it's working, right?
That's right.
The thing that I keep loving in the story, which is how often I'm surprised that we've seen this play out before in a very different context. So, you know, just the echoes of history in the story. I think EVs are perhaps like the cleanest example of this. I think many people might be shocked to know how far ahead EVs were at the turn of the century in the early 1900s. And we lived through this moment where people were trying to figure out swappable batteries and how would that work? And there are companies like better place, like 100 years ago, over 100 years ago, 125 years ago, there was a taxi fleet company in New York City that was doing swappable batteries for EVs.
And that was like the, you know, a dominant taxi fleet of the era, displacing the horse and carriage.
And there was a moment where like it was gas powered cars, EV cars, they were all equal,
could have gone any way
in terms of like what was going to take over the future.
I think you see again, this whipsaw around centralization, decentralization of power. We know well the early story of J.P. Morgan's house being lit by coal and, you know, his own dynamo. And with batteries and the advent of Powerwalls and Base Power, you're starting to get this re decentralization. After we went to the centralized grid,
what it means to be able to produce and consume your own power. What is the distributed energy generation movement really mean for people to island themselves off the grid to. There's a resilience component to it, but there's like an economic justice and ownership component to it, which is very powerful. As you think about marginalized communities that can now control more of their own destiny, have more economic livelihood because they have the ability to generate and consume their own power,
but also complicated, like the centralized grid with a mandate to serve all that we exited the 30s with as least in this country, was a democratic force, right?
Yeah, it was a beautiful thing. The Rural Electrification act was a beautiful thing.
There's an equalizing force. We're kind of shifting to a much more complicated world where if you can afford a battery and a rooftop solar like you might end up with a very, very different cost profile to your energy than if you're not. And who gets what is a brave new world of complexity as we figure out how to renavigate what it means that we can now store electricity
and means different things across different countries, right? Like you look at what's happening in East Africa and Pakistan with solar and batteries, and it's an entirely different topography that brings up this theme of reshaping the grid and reshaping our relationship to electricity. One question that has popped up through some of our interviews has been like, what would the grid look like if it were reinvented today with storage? One analogy was the refrigerator, right? Like previously, you had to grow and consume the food in a finite amount of time, similar to you have to generate and consume electricity in the exact same amount of time.
There's a long, complicated history about salt and storage. But at some point we invented the fridge and we had invented cold storage and we got supermarkets and we got the global food trade. And batteries are like the fridge of the electricity markets.
I like it. We both got EVs in the last couple years. And it changes your relationship to mobility entirely. I mean, obviously you don't think about going to a gas station. You just plug this thing in at home, at least in Washington, like, it's much, much cheaper. You're just like not thinking about mileage the same way. And it's just like, better. So there's something about going from the phone to the car. And then I feel like we're on the precipice of what does it mean when buildings by default have storage? Like, what does it mean for them to have the refrigeration, as you put it?
I feel like it means we're going to be used to much more abundant, cheap and reliable energy, which, like, is going to unlock a bunch of things for us.
Taking that further, what does it mean for the collective? You can imagine a grid that has full storage deployment, not necessarily worrying about large scale blackouts or outages,
right?
If a tree falls on a power line, the neighborhood battery system just kicks into gear. That problem becomes very isolated rather than taking down an entire region of the grid. The other thing I think it's going to, it's going to do is like in 50 years, look back and just marvel at how the grid stayed functioning through everything that we've put it through without storage. Like how it was built for the worst hour, how we developed these insanely complicated markets just to make sure that for a few hours A year you could supply power and then you've got like reserves and balancing and all these other different markets simply because we have to work around the fact that there is no storage.
Back to your food analogy. It's like you probably threw out a lot more rotten food because you had no refrigeration. And once you stop doing that, once you have refrigeration, you get to consume it as you need it and so just be much, much more efficient. From a waste perspective, I think you're right. 50 years from now we'll look back and be like wow, we had so much slack in the system and we thought we were constrained and we were so not constrained once you add this buffer to it.
One of the big themes I take away from this and just the joys of being able to take a moment to study China's role in batteries has been transformative. We have only scratched the surface and I have such a deeper appreciation for, for the power of the long view, the vision of the state five five year plans ago to say this is of national importance. This technology around batteries and eventually the application of buses and cars is of fundamental national security importance. We are going to invest in. They created the market signal.
They literally created the market by mandating that the buses and taxi fleets operate on EVs. They created the enabling environment, the financing, the land, the competition, the white lists for suppliers, all of it. That is a obviously one romantic version of it. There is a dark underbelly to China's manufacturing revolution. But the contrast to our VC funded lab research different by grants, policy, environment that is barely one administration long offers very little opportunity to build a market. And where we are today, just.
Just the pure facts of how little control we have over one of the most important energy technologies of the 21st century is a testament to the power of these different systems. And there are pros and cons to all of it. And so the question I'm left with is like okay, within our system, as a US citizen, what are our paths forward to reclaim more sovereignty and enable more affordable technology to be produced. But it is shocking and eye opening to me the level of concentration that exists within this one particular industry.
Yeah, batteries are one of the cleanest examples of Wright's learning law, right. And this idea that like they just get better as you make more of them and better means cheaper, it means you get better yield, it means you just get better at it. So it just requires longevity of manufacturing. The other clean example of this is solar panels. Also a thing that we've seen China completely dominate in the market. It seems that at least in the last X decades, like the US doesn't know how to build industries around Wright's Law, build industries where you factory manufacture things at scale and benefit from that kind of repeatability.
And there could be economic reasons why we don't like those products because generally they become more competitive, become commodities over time. All these other rationalizations. But it's a real geopolitical choice and I think the competitive geopolitical tension and the potential resilience, defense tension is real. I also put on a different hat which is more of like a global humanist view in that lens. I'm almost just frustrated that we're not reaping global collaboration as effectively as we can here. Right?
Totally.
And like we just talked about how this battery is this amazing global soup and every iPhone is that. And then it's manufactured in China. Like let's not fool ourselves. We've already live in a global context. Why would you want to inhibit us deploying more Chinese LFP batteries on our grid when there's not an alternative today?
Yeah. When we asked people about the relationship of China and the US and the stronghold that China has, I think the most consistent and compelling thought for the US was along lines of what you're saying, which is we should open the floodgates to every available technology and buy as much LFP batteries and, and the batteries that are being produced anywhere in Asia to enable the industries in this country while simultaneously working on that future technology. And if we accept the fact that it doesn't appear viable for us to build manufacturing at scale in the short term, we have a history of scientific progress and scientific breakthroughs.
We have, we, the US largely have driven most of the scientific breakthroughs in batteries. And, and there's a lot of good people working on that. And so let it all in. Enable the economies to grow and at the same time look forward at what's next. And hey, if we figure out how to do advanced manufacturing, this country, all the better.
A bigger political question for, I don't know, friends like Ezra Klein to figure out which is what should the US approach to industrial policy be that can be bipartisan. Right. Because they can transcend partisan politics. Because I don't think we want to move to a single party, CCP style world in this country. I prefer we don't.
Correct.
But there are certain categories where it would be great if we could make 10 to 20 year plans of investment and policy to incentivize collective human action on important topics. And in this mechanism we are just so whiplash back and forth that that feels impossible in these important categories. So
yeah, you know, maybe the place to end is the place where we begin, which is the wonder and amazement and magic of all of this. The chemistry and the manufacturing of this tiny little portable power source.
We chose this topic and talked to even some other people who have written about this topic. They talked about how often they'd bring up that this is what they're working on, the study, how many people's eyes would just glaze over like batteries. Like, why is that interesting? And as evidenced by us running way over the time that we thought we would need for this story, turns out it's pretty interesting. It affects us so many seconds of so many days in our regular life, affects our geopolitics, affects our energy system, affects our climate impact, affects so much about the path forward.
And it's changing right now, right? Like I, I think appreciating how much the next five years is going to look different and how different five years ago looked in some of these major moments. So I think it just really matters.
That's right, the image of massive distributed renewable energy solar farms and wind farms with battery backups creating firm power all enabled by sub micron level precision of manufacturing is just such a beautiful like do the little things really well to create big systems change.
I like that. And if you enjoyed this and have friends or colleagues that you think might find the story of batteries valuable, please send it their way. And please make sure you're subscribed to Stepchange in your podcast player of choice so you can find out when our next episode comes out and sign up for emails at stepchange.show. Podcast ratings make a huge difference to help people discover this, so we always appreciate them and comments and love hearing from listeners. You can send us an email anytime at hi@stepchange.show. We're already in debate about what the next topic or episode should be and so if you have a strong desire or vote, please send us an email.
And for our day job over at Stepchange Ventures, we invest in early stage companies accelerating energy abundance and critical infrastructure. So if you're a founder working on something in this space, please reach out to us. We have a few investments involving energy storage and we'd love to make some more.
And lastly, if this is the first episode of Stepchange you've listened to, we recommend you pop over to the feed and check out the story of the grid and the story of data centers. There's a lot of fun character crossover and tech crossover and stories all right, with that, we have some huge thank yous. First, to Base Power, our presenting sponsor for this episode. Base is building a network of home batteries that make the grid cheaper and more reliable. And they're hiring. You can find them@basepowercompany.com careers
and thank you to the Volta Foundation for partnering on this episode. We're excited for your annual battery report to drop in January. And thank you to our final sponsor, Crusoe, the vertically integrated AI company.
And thank you to everyone who helped us pull off this episode. We read about half a dozen great books, but the standouts were Steve LeVine's The Powerhouse, Seth Fletcher's Bottled Lightning, and James Morton Turner's Charged. Thank you to Brian Potter of Construction Physics and Hannah Ritchie from Our World in Data for their great writing. And to the king of battery substacks, Intercalation Station and their founder, Andrew Wang, who also runs a battery startup, Every Electric. And thank you to our friend Andy Lubershane from EIP, who writes the phenomenal Steel for Fuel substack and the time he spent with us unpacking the last 20 years of of battery developments.
And to the Volta Foundation for their deep annual battery report
and many others who spent generous hours with us. Martin Eberhard, a co founder of Tesla. Bob Galyen, who was CATL's first chief technology officer after already having an amazing career designing the EV1 battery pack.
And thank you to Brandon Middaugh, who's been a huge thought partner for us in this episode following all the all of her immense help on data centers and the grid.
Justin Lopas, co founder at Base Power. Andy Stevenson, who led the effort to build Redwood Materials alongside JB.
And thank you to Professor Jeff Dahn, who played a huge part in the lithium-ion story.
Celina Mikolajczak, who was foundational to cell quality at Tesla, Panasonic, QuantumScape and Lyten. Matias Alberola from the energy team at Crusoe, Sendil Palani for the stories of Tesla in pure startup mode.
And Kjell Schroder who worked in Goodenough's lab and has founded a new sodium-ion company here in Seattle, Emerald Battery Labs. And our favorite energy analysts and futurists, Ben James in the uk and Ramez Naam and Nat Bullard, fellow Seattleites. Nat has also recently launched his own great new podcast called Nameplate, where he's been interviewing utility CEOs. Highly recommend checking it out and thank you to Grayson Shor for his deep expertise on battery circularity, Wenzhuo Yang, CTO of Amplify
and thank you to a number of key operators in the space on grid scale deployments Jon Bonanno, Rick Winter, Praveen Kathpal and Lakshmi Srinivasan.
And a huge thank you to Dan Schwartz along with the whole group at the UW Clean Energy Testbeds for giving us a tour of a state of the art new battery lab that we're lucky to have here in Seattle.
And thank you to the people who will remain strictly on background. You know who you are and we appreciate you. And on podcasts thank you to the people and teams behind Volts, Catalyst, Inevitable, Energy Empire and Open Circuit. We listen to hours and it really helps us get up to speed on everything happening today in energy storage.
And thank you to Nick Petrie our editor and to Ben Gilbert from Acquired for the ongoing mentorship and advice with that until next time.
- The Powerhouse: Inside the Invention of a Battery to Save the World— Steve LeVine (2015)
- Bottled Lightning: Superbatteries, Electric Cars, and the New Lithium Economy— Seth Fletcher (2011)
- Charged: A History of Batteries and Lessons for a Clean Energy Future— James Morton Turner (2022)
- The Battery: How Portable Power Sparked a Technological Revolution— Henry Schlesinger (2010)
- Lithium: The Global Race for Battery Dominance and the New Energy Revolution— Lukasz Bednarski (2021)
- Electric Vehicle Batteries: From Sourcing to Second Life and Recycling— Bob Galyen & Frank Menchaca, eds. (Wiley, 2025)
- Energy and Civilization: A History— Vaclav Smil (2017)
Further reading
- Power Play: Tesla, Elon Musk, and the Bet of the Century— Tim Higgins (2021)
- Volt Rush: The Winners and Losers in the Race to Go Green— Henry Sanderson (2022)
- The War Below: Lithium, Copper, and the Global Battle to Power Our Lives— Ernest Scheyder (2024)
- Material World: A Substantial Story of Our Past and Future— Ed Conway (2023)
- Cobalt Red: How the Blood of the Congo Powers Our Lives— Siddharth Kara (2023)
- How Solar Energy Became Cheap: A Model for Low-Carbon Innovation— Gregory Nemet (2019)
- Ludicrous: The Unvarnished Story of Tesla Motors— Edward Niedermeyer (2019)
- Energy Myths and Realities— Vaclav Smil (2010)
- Edison, His Life and Inventions— Frank Lewis Dyer & Thomas Commerford Martin (1910)
We spoke with these people while researching the episode. Their time and expertise shaped the story; any errors are ours.
- Bob Galyen— First CTO of CATL; earlier led battery engineering on the GM EV1
- Martin Eberhard— Co-founder and first CEO of Tesla Motors
- Celina Mikolajczak— Battery advisor; formerly cell quality at Tesla, Panasonic Energy, QuantumScape and Lyten
- Jeff Dahn— Professor, Dalhousie University; longtime Tesla research partner
- Kjell Schroder— Founder, Emerald Battery Labs; trained in John Goodenough's lab
- Justin Lopas— Co-founder and COO, Base Power
- Andy Stevenson— Early Redwood Materials team, alongside JB Straubel
- Sendil Palani— Early Tesla, on the company's startup years
- Matias Alberola— Energy & infrastructure development, Crusoe
- Andy Lubershane— Partner and Head of Research, Energy Impact Partners; author of Steel for Fuel
- Andrew Wang— Co-founder, Every Electric; founder of the Intercalation Station newsletter
- Ben James— Author, The Big Guide to Batteries
- Ramez Naam— Founder, Planetary VC; author and energy futurist
- Grayson Shor— Battery circularity and critical minerals, Buckstop
- Wenzhuo Yang— CTO, Amplify Cell Technologies
- Jon Bonanno— Factor
- Rick Winter— CEO, CHARG Energy
- Praveen Kathpal— Early AES Energy Storage and Fluence
- Lakshmi Srinivasan— Early Tesla Energy (Powerwall and Powerpack)
- Dan Schwartz— UW Clean Energy Institute and the Washington Clean Energy Testbeds
- Steve LeVine— Author of The Powerhouse; Editor, The Electric at The Information
- Nick Perkins— Tesla Model 3 and Gigafactory ramp; Form Energy
Shows we listened to throughout
- Volts— David Roberts
- Catalyst with Shayle Kann— Canary Media
- Open Circuit— Latitude Media
- Inevitable— MCJ
- Energy Empire
- Nameplate— Nat Bullard
Episodes we drew on
- ASCENT — "CATL"— (May 2026)
- Acquired — "Tesla"— (July 2018)
- ChinaTalk — "The Rise of China's Electric Vehicle Industry"— (August 2026)
- Driving with Dunne — "BYD: The Roar of China's EV Powerhouse"— (June 2023)
- Odd Lots — "The Chinese EV Maker That's Selling More Cars Than Tesla"— (August 2023)
- Inevitable — Marc Tarpenning— (September 2025)
- Volts — "What's the deal with pumped-hydro energy storage?"— (January 2025)
- Volts — "Silicon anodes for batteries unlock greater energy density and faster charging times"— (July 2026)
- Catalyst — "What do you do with a 100-hour battery?"— (December 2023)
- Catalyst — "GM's big new battery tech push"— (June 2025)
- Catalyst — "How China is reshaping the global auto market"— (June 2026)
- Catalyst — "The multi-billion dollar promise of vehicle-to-grid integration"— (July 2026)
- Catalyst — "The commercial battery comeback"— (July 2026)
- Catalyst — "The rise of metal fuels"— (August 2026)
- Open Circuit — "Green Blueprint: Form's storage manufacturing breakthrough"— (August 2026)
- Inevitable — "Fourier Is Solving Long-Duration Storage with On-Site Hydrogen"— (September 2026)
- Positive Charge (GeekWire) — "Your used EV battery isn't dead — it's being resurrected to power the grid"— (2026)
- Battery Potential — "Jeff Dahn: Moli Energy"— (February 2026)
- The Big Guide to Batteries— Ben James
- Construction Physics— Brian Potter, especially "How We Got the Lithium-Ion Battery"
- Our World in Data— Hannah Ritchie, "Battery price decline"
- Intercalation Station— battery science and industry newsletter
- Steel for Fuel— Andy Lubershane, Energy Impact Partners
- Decarbonization presentations— Nat Bullard
- How Electricity Actually Works— Veritasium
- World's Largest Batteries (Pumped Storage)— Practical Engineering
- Battery Report (2020–2025 editions)— Volta Foundation
- Global EV Outlook 2024, 2025 and 2026: EV batteries— International Energy Agencyiea.org (2025) · iea.org (2024)
- Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2025— International Energy Agency
- Lithium-ion battery pack price survey— BloombergNEF
- Re-examining rates of lithium-ion battery technology improvement and cost decline— Micah Ziegler & Jessika Trancik (2021)
- Battery storage capacity averaged 70% growth over the last three years— US Energy Information Administration, Today in Energy
- ERCOT battery buildout: 2025 annual report— Modo Energy
- California surpasses 21,000 MW of battery resources— California Energy Commission (August 2026)
- Hornsdale Power Reserve Impact Study, Years 1 and 2— Aurecon (2018, 2020)
- Black System South Australia, 28 September 2016: final report— Australian Energy Market Commission (2017)
- DOE/EPRI Energy Storage Handbook— Sandia National Laboratories
- Scientific background on the 2019 Nobel Prize in Chemistry— Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences
- The Toxic Truth: Children's Exposure to Lead Pollution— UNICEF & Pure Earth (2020)
The first batteries
- The Discovery of the Battery and The Column Battery— alessandrovolta.it
- The First Battery— IEEE Spectrum
- Gaston Planté and his invention of the lead–acid battery— Peter Kurzweil, Journal of Power Sources (2010)
- Report on the Faure Accumulator— Sir William Thomson (Lord Kelvin), 1881
- The False Start: British Electrification, 1880–1888— Leslie Hannah, Enterprise & Society
- The driving force: the story of The Electrical Power Storage Company— IET Archives (2022)
Lead-acid and the car
- Lead Poisoning in the Manufacture of Storage Batteries— Alice Hamilton, US Bureau of Labor Statistics Bulletin 165 (1914)
- Cadillac's great leap forward: the 1912 electric starter— Mac's Motor City Garage
- History of New York's 19th-century electric cabs— National Geographic
- States' Efforts to Promote Lead-Acid Battery Recycling— US EPA (1992)
- Lead Poisoning: Then and Now— Leif Fredrickson, We're History (2016)
Lithium-ion
- Lithium-ion battery history— IEEE Spectrum
- John Goodenough 1922–2023: a retrospective on his patents— Carpmaels & Ransford
- Moli Energy lithium battery technology— Electric Autonomy (2020)
- Stanley Whittingham transcript— International Battery Seminar
- Dell announces recall of notebook computer batteries due to fire hazard— US Consumer Product Safety Commission (2006)
Tesla, A123 and the EV revival
- Mythbusting: the truth about the GM EV1— Gary Witzenburg, Hagerty
- Who Killed the Electric Car?— Chris Paine (2006)
- Why A123 didn't get the Volt contract— MIT Technology Review (2008)
- Cash-fueled climb led to fall of A123 Systems— Boston Globe (2012)
- A short (updated) story of A123Systems— Ric Fulop
- Collapse of Battery Startup Envia: What Really Happened— Green Car Reports (2013)
- Panasonic putting $1.6 billion into Tesla Gigafactory— CleanTechnica (2016)
China and the supply chain
- Robin Zeng: CATL's Prodigious Gambler— Interconnected
- It's Not Just Subsidies: How China's EV Battery Firms Learned Their Way to Dominance— Stanford Center on China's Economy and Institutions
- The big read: history of BYD— CarNewsChina (2021)
- Global EV battery market share, 2025— CnEVPost, from SNE Research
- Graphite mining pollution in China— The Washington Post (2016)
Batteries on the grid
- AES Laurel Mountain: frequency regulation services— Energy Storage Association archive
- Moss Landing Energy Storage Facility online— Vistra (2021)
- Battery storage failure incident rate dropped 97% between 2018 and 2023— Energy-Storage.News, from EPRI (2024)
The frontier
- Innovating to Zero!— Bill Gates, TED (2010)
